{
 "schemaVersion": 2,
 "version": "2.1.0",
 "snapshotId": "faultline-crossdomain-2.1.0-2026-10-30",
 "generated": "2026-10-30",
 "generator": "scripts/build-crossdomain.mjs",
 "description": "Cross-domain linkage snapshot for Faultline. Records come from four analyst-coded platform datasets. Links are derived only from fields present in those datasets, through the crosswalk tables included here.",
 "sources": {
  "cyber": {
   "name": "Cyber Escalation Atlas",
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app",
   "repo": "cyber-escalation-atlas",
   "commit": "8bc0031951bf5daf46a362c776783d9defc54f4e",
   "commitDate": "2026-10-29",
   "dataClean": true,
   "branch": "claude/gtc-hardening",
   "deployedBranch": "claude/setup-cyber-atlas-scaffold-ieuDR",
   "deployedBranchSource": "origin/HEAD (default branch)",
   "onDeployedBranch": false,
   "files": [
    "src/data/incidents/index.ts (seed.ts, newCases2024.ts, newCasesGlobal.ts, newCasesAttribution.ts, attributionData.ts)",
    "src/data/legalFrameworks.ts",
    "src/data/norms.ts",
    "src/data/actors.ts",
    "src/data/tallinnRules.ts"
   ],
   "records": 33,
   "recordTypes": {
    "case": 33
   }
  },
  "orbital": {
   "name": "Orbital Risk Tracker",
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app",
   "repo": "Orbital-Risk-Tracker",
   "commit": "e219b829477ff104dcc17712338963dbf614a4e5",
   "commitDate": "2026-10-29",
   "dataClean": true,
   "branch": "claude/gtc-hardening",
   "deployedBranch": "claude/space-incidents-dashboard-HOnqa",
   "deployedBranchSource": "origin/HEAD (default branch)",
   "onDeployedBranch": false,
   "files": [
    "src/data/incidents.js",
    "src/data/legalFramework.js",
    "src/data/actors.js"
   ],
   "records": 28,
   "recordTypes": {
    "incident": 28
   }
  },
  "nuclear": {
   "name": "Global Nuclear Infrastructure Atlas",
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app",
   "repo": "Global-Nuclear-Infrastructure-Atlas",
   "commit": "daadd82d0f23854b2ea624c8696aaa728d7cdee6",
   "commitDate": "2026-10-29",
   "dataClean": true,
   "branch": "claude/gtc-hardening",
   "deployedBranch": "claude/nuclear-infrastructure-atlas-IIjPg",
   "deployedBranchSource": "origin/HEAD (default branch)",
   "onDeployedBranch": false,
   "files": [
    "src/data/commercialPlants.js",
    "src/data/enrichedFacilities.js (digital I&C and cyber overlay fields)",
    "src/data/countryGovernance.js",
    "src/data/countryPolicies.js"
   ],
   "records": 86,
   "recordTypes": {
    "plant": 86
   }
  },
  "lunar": {
   "name": "Lunar Governance Tracker",
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app",
   "repo": "lunar-mandate-atlas",
   "commit": "d3d48a1d807508867324b3196794c69330a72f48",
   "commitDate": "2026-10-30",
   "dataClean": true,
   "branch": "claude/gtc-hardening",
   "deployedBranch": "claude/lunar-governance-tracker-txA5R",
   "deployedBranchSource": "origin/HEAD (default branch)",
   "onDeployedBranch": false,
   "files": [
    "src/data/discretionPoints.ts",
    "src/data/countries.ts",
    "src/data/infrastructure.ts",
    "src/data/constants.ts",
    "src/data/documents.ts"
   ],
   "records": 31,
   "recordTypes": {
    "discretion-point": 16,
    "country-profile": 8,
    "infrastructure-link": 7
   }
  }
 },
 "counts": {
  "records": 178,
  "entities": 76,
  "entitiesByType": {
   "state": 41,
   "sector": 3,
   "instrument": 32
  },
  "nodes": 254,
  "attributeEdges": 407,
  "attributeEdgesByBasis": {
   "attributed_state": 42,
   "target_state": 56,
   "host_state": 86,
   "profiled_state": 8,
   "infrastructure_category": 122,
   "instrument_referenced": 93
  },
  "links": 6,
  "linksByBasis": {
   "same_intrusion_set": 6,
   "same_event": 1
  },
  "linksByDomainPair": {
   "cyber-orbital": 6
  },
  "linksByTier": {
   "same-event": 1,
   "same-intrusion-set": 5
  },
  "linksByTierAndDomainPair": {
   "cyber-orbital": {
    "same-event": 1,
    "same-intrusion-set": 5
   }
  },
  "illustrativeExcluded": 4,
  "orbitalIncidentsTotalInSource": 32,
  "stateContextEdges": 112,
  "facets": 25,
  "facetsByType": {
   "state": 22,
   "sector": 3
  },
  "actorsNotResolved": 13
 },
 "tiers": {
  "same-event": "The same incident is recorded in both datasets: same name and year, a cited source naming both (relatedRecords), or the same named target in the same year.",
  "same-intrusion-set": "The records list the same MITRE ATT&CK group (intrusionSetIds); without IDs, a cyber alias appears in the orbital actor field. They may be different operations by the same group."
 },
 "tierOfBasis": {
  "same_event": "same-event",
  "same_intrusion_set": "same-intrusion-set"
 },
 "tierRule": "A link is same-event when one of its bases is same_event; otherwise it is same-intrusion-set. Shared states and infrastructure categories are reported as facets, not links.",
 "facetRule": "A facet lists a state or infrastructure category that records in two or more datasets connect to, with the records and their role in each dataset (actor, target, host, profiled, category). It says the datasets both include the entity, not that the records are related.",
 "basisTypes": {
  "same_event": "Same incident recorded in two datasets",
  "same_intrusion_set": "Same intrusion set named in both records",
  "attributed_state": "Record names this state as the acting state",
  "target_state": "Record names this state as a target",
  "host_state": "Record is located in this state",
  "profiled_state": "State profiled in lunar data (a country authority profile, not an actor in an event)",
  "infrastructure_category": "Record falls in this shared infrastructure category (see crosswalk)",
  "instrument_referenced": "Record references this instrument"
 },
 "crosswalks": {
  "states": [
   {
    "id": "state:united-states",
    "label": "United States",
    "spellings": [
     "United States",
     "USA",
     "US"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:russia",
    "label": "Russia",
    "spellings": [
     "Russia"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:china",
    "label": "China",
    "spellings": [
     "China"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:united-kingdom",
    "label": "United Kingdom",
    "spellings": [
     "United Kingdom",
     "UK"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:france",
    "label": "France",
    "spellings": [
     "France"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:germany",
    "label": "Germany",
    "spellings": [
     "Germany"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:ukraine",
    "label": "Ukraine",
    "spellings": [
     "Ukraine"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:japan",
    "label": "Japan",
    "spellings": [
     "Japan"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:south-korea",
    "label": "South Korea",
    "spellings": [
     "South Korea"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:north-korea",
    "label": "North Korea",
    "spellings": [
     "North Korea"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:india",
    "label": "India",
    "spellings": [
     "India"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:pakistan",
    "label": "Pakistan",
    "spellings": [
     "Pakistan"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:iran",
    "label": "Iran",
    "spellings": [
     "Iran"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:israel",
    "label": "Israel",
    "spellings": [
     "Israel"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:united-arab-emirates",
    "label": "United Arab Emirates",
    "spellings": [
     "United Arab Emirates",
     "UAE"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:luxembourg",
    "label": "Luxembourg",
    "spellings": [
     "Luxembourg"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:eu-esa",
    "label": "European Union / ESA",
    "spellings": [
     "ESA / European Union",
     "EU / ESA"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:canada",
    "label": "Canada",
    "spellings": [
     "Canada"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:australia",
    "label": "Australia",
    "spellings": [
     "Australia"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:taiwan",
    "label": "Taiwan",
    "spellings": [
     "Taiwan"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:italy",
    "label": "Italy",
    "spellings": [
     "Italy"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:netherlands",
    "label": "Netherlands",
    "spellings": [
     "Netherlands"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:sweden",
    "label": "Sweden",
    "spellings": [
     "Sweden"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:switzerland",
    "label": "Switzerland",
    "spellings": [
     "Switzerland"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:brazil",
    "label": "Brazil",
    "spellings": [
     "Brazil"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:belgium",
    "label": "Belgium",
    "spellings": [
     "Belgium"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:saudi-arabia",
    "label": "Saudi Arabia",
    "spellings": [
     "Saudi Arabia"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:bangladesh",
    "label": "Bangladesh",
    "spellings": [
     "Bangladesh"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:egypt",
    "label": "Egypt",
    "spellings": [
     "Egypt"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:finland",
    "label": "Finland",
    "spellings": [
     "Finland"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:czech-republic",
    "label": "Czech Republic",
    "spellings": [
     "Czech Republic"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:hungary",
    "label": "Hungary",
    "spellings": [
     "Hungary"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:spain",
    "label": "Spain",
    "spellings": [
     "Spain"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:argentina",
    "label": "Argentina",
    "spellings": [
     "Argentina"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:south-africa",
    "label": "South Africa",
    "spellings": [
     "South Africa"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:mexico",
    "label": "Mexico",
    "spellings": [
     "Mexico"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:romania",
    "label": "Romania",
    "spellings": [
     "Romania"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:slovenia",
    "label": "Slovenia",
    "spellings": [
     "Slovenia"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:armenia",
    "label": "Armenia",
    "spellings": [
     "Armenia"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:belarus",
    "label": "Belarus",
    "spellings": [
     "Belarus"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "state:turkey",
    "label": "Turkey",
    "spellings": [
     "Turkey"
    ]
   }
  ],
  "stateRule": "A field is linked to a state only when its value, with any parenthetical removed and split on '/', matches a listed spelling exactly. Values such as 'Unknown', 'Multiple', 'Global' or 'Central Europe' are not linked. An actor field is not linked when a parenthetical says the actor is criminal, not the state, individuals or similar, or when the record's attribution confidence is below high.",
  "sectors": [
   {
    "id": "energy-power",
    "label": "Energy and power",
    "rules": [
     {
      "domain": "cyber",
      "field": "infrastructure.targetSectors",
      "match": "energy"
     },
     {
      "domain": "nuclear",
      "field": "(record type)",
      "match": "every commercial nuclear power plant record"
     },
     {
      "domain": "lunar",
      "field": "INFRA_GOVERNANCE_LINKS.infrastructure",
      "match": "power"
     }
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "communications",
    "label": "Communications",
    "rules": [
     {
      "domain": "cyber",
      "field": "infrastructure.targetSectors",
      "match": "telecommunications"
     },
     {
      "domain": "orbital",
      "field": "target or subtype",
      "match": "text contains: communication, satellite internet, broadband, Starlink, KA-SAT, SATCOM"
     },
     {
      "domain": "lunar",
      "field": "INFRA_GOVERNANCE_LINKS.infrastructure",
      "match": "comms"
     }
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "navigation-timing",
    "label": "Navigation and timing",
    "rules": [
     {
      "domain": "orbital",
      "field": "type, subtype, target",
      "match": "type is spoofing, or subtype or target text contains GNSS or GPS"
     },
     {
      "domain": "lunar",
      "field": "INFRA_GOVERNANCE_LINKS.infrastructure",
      "match": "nav"
     }
    ]
   }
  ],
  "instruments": [
   {
    "id": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
    "label": "Outer Space Treaty (1967)",
    "pattern": "^(outer space treaty|ost)\\b",
    "sourceIds": [
     "OST-1967",
     "OST"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:liability-convention",
    "label": "Liability Convention (1972)",
    "pattern": "^liability convention",
    "sourceIds": [
     "LIABILITY"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:registration-convention",
    "label": "Registration Convention (1975)",
    "pattern": "^registration convention",
    "sourceIds": [
     "REGISTRATION"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
    "label": "COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019)",
    "pattern": "^copuos lts guidelines",
    "sourceIds": [
     "LTS"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:artemis-accords",
    "label": "Artemis Accords",
    "pattern": "^artemis accords$",
    "sourceIds": [
     "AA-2020",
     "ARTEMIS"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:itu-framework",
    "label": "ITU Coordination",
    "pattern": "^itu coordination",
    "sourceIds": [
     "ITU"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
    "label": "Tallinn Manual 2.0",
    "pattern": "^tallinn manual 2\\.0",
    "sourceIds": [
     "tallinn"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:un-charter",
    "label": "UN Charter",
    "pattern": "^un charter",
    "sourceIds": [
     "un-charter"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:ihl",
    "label": "Geneva Conventions / IHL",
    "pattern": "^(geneva conventions|ihl\\b)",
    "sourceIds": [
     "ihl"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
    "label": "UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015)",
    "pattern": "^un gge 2015",
    "sourceIds": [
     "gge-norms"
    ]
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:npt",
    "label": "NPT",
    "pattern": "^npt$",
    "sourceIds": []
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
    "label": "IAEA Additional Protocol",
    "pattern": "^additional protocol$",
    "sourceIds": []
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:euratom",
    "label": "EURATOM",
    "pattern": "^euratom$",
    "sourceIds": []
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:tlatelolco",
    "label": "Treaty of Tlatelolco",
    "pattern": "^tlatelolco treaty$",
    "sourceIds": []
   },
   {
    "id": "instrument:pelindaba",
    "label": "Treaty of Pelindaba",
    "pattern": "^pelindaba treaty$",
    "sourceIds": []
   }
  ],
  "instrumentRule": "Instrument strings are mapped to a canonical instrument when they match a listed pattern or source id. Unmatched strings keep their own instrument node."
 },
 "nodes": [
  {
   "id": "cyber:notpetya",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "NotPetya",
   "date": "June 2017",
   "year": 2017,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/notpetya",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Destructive wiper malware disguised as ransomware, distributed via a compromised Ukrainian tax software update. Caused an estimated $10B+ in global damages, primarily affecting shipping, logistics, and pharmaceutical…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "destructive",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Sandworm",
     "Voodoo Bear",
     "IRIDIUM"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "transportation",
     "manufacturing",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "UA"
    ],
    "geographicScope": "global",
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0034"
    ],
    "organ": "GRU",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:solarwinds",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "SolarWinds (Sunburst)",
   "date": "March 2020 – December 2020",
   "year": 2020,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/solarwinds",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Sophisticated supply chain compromise of SolarWinds Orion IT monitoring platform, enabling covert access to ~18,000 organizations including US federal agencies. Discovered in December 2020 after ~9 months of undetected…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "APT29",
     "Cozy Bear",
     "Nobelium",
     "Midnight Blizzard"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government",
     "technology",
     "defense"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US",
     "GB"
    ],
    "geographicScope": "nato-allies",
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0016"
    ],
    "organ": "SVR",
    "targetEntities": [
     "SolarWinds"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:stuxnet",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Stuxnet",
   "date": "circa 2007 – 2010",
   "year": 2010,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/stuxnet",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "A precision cyber weapon that targeted Siemens SCADA systems controlling uranium-enrichment centrifuges at Iran's Natanz facility. It caused physical destruction of centrifuges while reporting normal telemetry to…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "sabotage",
    "attributionCountry": "United States / Israel",
    "attributionConfidence": "moderate",
    "aliases": [
     "Olympic Games"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "energy",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "IR"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "Natanz enrichment facility"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:sony-pictures",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Sony Pictures Entertainment Hack",
   "date": "November – December 2014",
   "year": 2014,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/sony-pictures",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Destructive intrusion into Sony Pictures Entertainment that exfiltrated confidential data and deployed wiper malware, rendering thousands of workstations inoperable. Accompanied by coercive threats linked to the film…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "destructive",
    "attributionCountry": "North Korea",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Lazarus Group",
     "HIDDEN COBRA",
     "Guardians of Peace"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "media"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0032"
    ],
    "organ": "RGB",
    "targetEntities": [
     "Sony Pictures Entertainment"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Ukraine Power Grid Attack (2015)",
   "date": "December 2015",
   "year": 2015,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Coordinated cyber attack against three Ukrainian regional power distribution companies that caused power outages affecting approximately 230,000 customers. Attackers used spearphishing for initial access, then…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "sabotage",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Sandworm",
     "Voodoo Bear",
     "IRIDIUM"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "energy",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "UA"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0034"
    ],
    "organ": "GRU",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Ukraine Power Grid Attack (2016 / Industroyer)",
   "date": "December 2016",
   "year": 2016,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/ukraine-power-grid-2016",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "A more sophisticated follow-up to the 2015 grid attack, this operation used purpose-built ICS malware (Industroyer/CrashOverride) capable of directly speaking industrial protocols to open circuit breakers. It caused a…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "sabotage",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Sandworm",
     "Voodoo Bear",
     "IRIDIUM"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "energy",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "UA"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0034"
    ],
    "organ": "GRU",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:wannacry",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "WannaCry Ransomware",
   "date": "May 2017",
   "year": 2017,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/wannacry",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Self-propagating ransomware that exploited the EternalBlue SMB vulnerability to spread across ~150 countries in hours. The UK's National Health Service was among the hardest hit, with hospitals diverting ambulances and…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "ransomware",
    "attributionCountry": "North Korea",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Lazarus Group",
     "HIDDEN COBRA"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "healthcare",
     "telecommunications",
     "transportation",
     "manufacturing"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [],
    "geographicScope": "global",
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0032"
    ],
    "organ": "RGB",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Colonial Pipeline Ransomware Attack",
   "date": "May 2021",
   "year": 2021,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/colonial-pipeline",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "DarkSide ransomware group encrypted IT systems at Colonial Pipeline, operator of the largest refined-fuel pipeline in the US. The company preemptively shut down OT pipeline operations for six days, triggering fuel…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "ransomware",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia (criminal, not directly state-sponsored per US assessment)",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "DarkSide",
     "BlackMatter"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "energy",
     "critical-infrastructure",
     "transportation"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "Colonial Pipeline"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:oldsmar-water",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Oldsmar Water Treatment Plant Intrusion",
   "date": "February 2021",
   "year": 2021,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/oldsmar-water",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "An unauthorized actor remotely accessed the SCADA system at the Oldsmar, Florida water treatment plant via TeamViewer and attempted to increase sodium hydroxide (lye) levels to potentially dangerous concentrations. An…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "sabotage",
    "attributionCountry": "Unknown",
    "attributionConfidence": "low",
    "aliases": [],
    "targetSectors": [
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "Oldsmar water treatment plant"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Viasat KA-SAT (AcidRain)",
   "date": "February 2022",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/viasat-kasat",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Destructive cyber attack against Viasat's KA-SAT satellite broadband network, timed to coincide with Russia's invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022. AcidRain wiper malware bricked tens of thousands of satellite…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "destructive",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Sandworm"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "telecommunications",
     "defense",
     "energy",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "UA",
     "DE",
     "FR",
     "IT"
    ],
    "geographicScope": "central-europe",
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0034"
    ],
    "organ": "GRU",
    "targetEntities": [
     "Viasat KA-SAT"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:exchange-hafnium",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Microsoft Exchange Server Exploitation (Hafnium)",
   "date": "January – March 2021",
   "year": 2021,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/exchange-hafnium",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Mass exploitation of four zero-day vulnerabilities in on-premises Microsoft Exchange Server by a China-based group, later followed by indiscriminate exploitation by multiple actors after patches were released. At least…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "China",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Hafnium",
     "Silk Typhoon"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government",
     "defense",
     "healthcare",
     "education",
     "technology"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "geographicScope": "global",
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0125"
    ],
    "organ": "MSS",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:costa-rica-conti",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Costa Rica Government Ransomware Attack",
   "date": "April – May 2022",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/costa-rica-conti",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Conti ransomware group attacked multiple Costa Rican government ministries, encrypting systems at the Ministry of Finance, disabling tax and customs platforms, and demanding a $20M ransom (later reduced to $10M). Costa…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "ransomware",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia (criminal, not directly state-sponsored per public assessments)",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "Conti",
     "Wizard Spider",
     "HIVE"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government",
     "finance",
     "healthcare"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "CR"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0102"
    ],
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:albania-iran",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Albania Government Cyber Attack",
   "date": "July – September 2022",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/albania-iran",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Iran-linked actors launched destructive cyber attacks against Albanian government systems, deploying wiper malware and ransomware that took e-government services offline for weeks. Albania attributed the attack to Iran…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "destructive",
    "attributionCountry": "Iran",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Homeland Justice",
     "DEV-0861",
     "DEV-0166"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "AL"
    ],
    "organ": "MOIS",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:shamoon-aramco",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Saudi Aramco Shamoon Attack",
   "date": "August 2012",
   "year": 2012,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/shamoon-aramco",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "The Shamoon wiper malware destroyed data on approximately 35,000 workstations at Saudi Aramco, the world's largest oil company. The attack overwrote master boot records with an image of a burning US flag. Aramco was…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "destructive",
    "attributionCountry": "Iran (assessed)",
    "attributionConfidence": "moderate",
    "aliases": [
     "APT33",
     "Elfin",
     "Cutting Sword of Justice"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "energy"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "SA"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0064"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "Saudi Aramco"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:bangladesh-bank-swift",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Bangladesh Bank SWIFT Heist",
   "date": "February 2016",
   "year": 2016,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/bangladesh-bank-swift",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Attackers compromised Bangladesh Bank's SWIFT terminal and issued fraudulent transfer requests totaling $951M from its account at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Most transactions were blocked, but $81M was…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "hybrid",
    "attributionCountry": "North Korea",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Lazarus Group",
     "APT38",
     "BlueNoroff"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "finance"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "BD",
     "PH"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0032",
     "G0082"
    ],
    "organ": "RGB",
    "targetEntities": [
     "Bangladesh Bank"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:australia-parliament",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Australian Parliament and Political Party Intrusions",
   "date": "January – February 2019",
   "year": 2019,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/australia-parliament",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Intrusions into the Australian Parliament House network and the networks of three major political parties, discovered weeks before a federal election. Australia's Prime Minister publicly attributed the activity to a…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "Unknown (officially); China (widely assessed)",
    "attributionConfidence": "moderate",
    "aliases": [],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "AU"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "Australian Parliament House"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:iran-nuclear-cyber",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Iran Nuclear Facilities – Cyber Incidents (2020–2021)",
   "date": "2020 – 2021",
   "year": 2020,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/iran-nuclear-cyber",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "A series of reported cyber-enabled incidents at Iranian nuclear and industrial facilities, including an explosion and fire at the Natanz enrichment plant (July 2020), a power distribution disruption at Natanz (April…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "sabotage",
    "attributionCountry": "Israel (attributed by Iran; not officially confirmed)",
    "attributionConfidence": "low",
    "aliases": [],
    "targetSectors": [
     "energy",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "IR"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "Natanz enrichment facility"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:taiwan-telecom",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Taiwan Telecommunications Intrusions",
   "date": "2022 – 2023 (disclosed 2023)",
   "year": 2023,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/taiwan-telecom",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Sustained intrusions into Taiwanese telecommunications providers attributed to China-linked threat groups, part of a broader pattern of pre-positioning in critical infrastructure. The campaigns, overlapping with…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "China (assessed)",
    "attributionConfidence": "moderate",
    "aliases": [
     "Volt Typhoon",
     "Flax Typhoon"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "telecommunications",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "TW"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G1017"
    ],
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:industroyer2",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Industroyer2 – Ukraine Grid Attack Attempt",
   "date": "April 2022",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/industroyer2",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Sandworm deployed Industroyer2, an updated variant of the 2016 Industroyer malware, against a Ukrainian regional energy company during Russia's ongoing invasion. The attack aimed to de-energize electrical substations…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "sabotage",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "Sandworm",
     "Voodoo Bear",
     "IRIDIUM"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "energy",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "UA"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0034"
    ],
    "organ": "GRU",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:scattered-spider-mgm",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Scattered Spider – MGM Resorts & Caesars Entertainment",
   "date": "September 2023",
   "year": 2023,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/scattered-spider-mgm",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "The Scattered Spider threat group, composed largely of English-speaking individuals using social engineering and SIM-swapping, compromised MGM Resorts and Caesars Entertainment. Caesars reportedly paid approximately…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "ransomware",
    "attributionCountry": "United States / United Kingdom (individuals; not state-sponsored)",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "Scattered Spider",
     "UNC3944",
     "Octo Tempest",
     "0ktapus"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "hospitality"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G1015"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "MGM Resorts",
     "Caesars Entertainment"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:storm-0558",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Microsoft Storm-0558 Cloud Email Compromise",
   "date": "May – July 2023",
   "year": 2023,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/storm-0558",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "China-linked espionage operation exploiting a forged Microsoft account signing key to access Outlook Web Access and Outlook.com email accounts of approximately 25 organizations, including US State Department and…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "China",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "Storm-0558"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government",
     "technology"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "Microsoft"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:change-healthcare",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Change Healthcare Ransomware Attack",
   "date": "February 2024",
   "year": 2024,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/change-healthcare",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "ALPHV/BlackCat ransomware attack on Change Healthcare, a UnitedHealth Group subsidiary processing approximately one-third of all US healthcare claims. The attack disrupted prescription processing, insurance claims, and…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "ransomware",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia (criminal, possible state nexus)",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "ALPHV",
     "BlackCat",
     "Noberus"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "healthcare",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "Change Healthcare"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:volt-typhoon",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Volt Typhoon, US Critical Infrastructure Pre-positioning",
   "date": "2023 – 2024 (disclosed 2024)",
   "year": 2024,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/volt-typhoon",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "PRC-linked threat actor assessed to be pre-positioning access in US critical infrastructure, including water, energy, communications, and transportation systems, as preparation for potential disruptive operations in a…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "China",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Volt Typhoon",
     "BRONZE SILHOUETTE",
     "Vanguard Panda"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "critical-infrastructure",
     "energy",
     "telecommunications",
     "transportation"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US",
     "GU"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G1017"
    ],
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:midnight-blizzard",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Microsoft Midnight Blizzard Corporate Intrusion",
   "date": "November 2023 – January 2024 (disclosed January 2024)",
   "year": 2024,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/midnight-blizzard",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "SVR/Cozy Bear intrusion into Microsoft's corporate environment via a password spray attack on a legacy test tenant, subsequently accessing source code repositories and internal email communications of senior leadership…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "Midnight Blizzard",
     "APT29",
     "Cozy Bear",
     "Nobelium"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "technology"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0016"
    ],
    "organ": "SVR",
    "targetEntities": [
     "Microsoft"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:kyivstar",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Kyivstar Telecommunications Attack",
   "date": "December 2023",
   "year": 2023,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/kyivstar",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Sandworm attack destroying the core network of Kyivstar, Ukraine's largest mobile operator serving approximately 24 million subscribers. The attack wiped network infrastructure and disrupted mobile communications,…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "destructive",
    "attributionCountry": "Russia",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "Sandworm",
     "Voodoo Bear",
     "IRIDIUM",
     "Seashell Blizzard"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "telecommunications",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "UA"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0034"
    ],
    "organ": "GRU",
    "targetEntities": [
     "Kyivstar"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:india-pakistan-cyber",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "India–Pakistan Cyber Operations",
   "date": "2016 – 2019 (multiple incidents)",
   "year": 2018,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/india-pakistan-cyber",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Reciprocal intrusion campaigns between Indian and Pakistani state-linked actors targeting government, military, and media sectors. The most documented South Asian cyber conflict pattern, involving persistent espionage…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "India / Pakistan (reciprocal)",
    "attributionConfidence": "moderate",
    "aliases": [
     "Transparent Tribe",
     "APT36",
     "SideWinder",
     "Patchwork",
     "Gorgon Group"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government",
     "defense",
     "media"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "IN",
     "PK"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0134",
     "G0121",
     "G0040",
     "G0078"
    ],
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:apt-c23-gaza-cybergang",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "APT-C-23 / Gaza Cybergang Operations",
   "date": "2018 – 2022 (ongoing, landmark incidents)",
   "year": 2020,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/apt-c23-gaza-cybergang",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Hamas-linked threat actor conducting espionage against Palestinian Authority officials, Israeli military and security personnel, and regional governments using sophisticated mobile malware and social engineering.…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "Palestinian Territories (Hamas-linked)",
    "attributionConfidence": "moderate",
    "aliases": [
     "APT-C-23",
     "Arid Viper",
     "Desert Falcon",
     "Gaza Cybergang"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government",
     "defense"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "IL",
     "PS",
     "EG"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G1028"
    ],
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Belgacom / Operation Socialist",
   "date": "circa 2010 – disclosed September 2013",
   "year": 2013,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/belgacom-operation-socialist",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Multi-year intrusion into Belgacom, Belgium's largest telecommunications operator and at the time a majority state-owned carrier of EU institutional and NATO traffic. Snowden documents disclosed in September 2013…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "United Kingdom",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "Operation Socialist",
     "Regin (toolset)"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "telecommunications",
     "critical-infrastructure"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "BE"
    ],
    "organ": "GCHQ",
    "targetEntities": [
     "Belgacom"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:opm-breach",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "OPM Data Breach",
   "date": "2014 – disclosed June 2015",
   "year": 2015,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/opm-breach",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Intrusion into the US Office of Personnel Management resulting in exfiltration of personnel records on approximately 21.5 million current and former federal employees, contractors, and family members, including…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "China",
    "attributionConfidence": "high",
    "aliases": [
     "Deep Panda",
     "Axiom (linked tooling)"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government",
     "defense"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0009",
     "G0001"
    ],
    "targetEntities": [
     "US Office of Personnel Management"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "APT1 / PLA Unit 61398 Economic Espionage",
   "date": "2006 – disclosed February 2013; indictment May 2014",
   "year": 2013,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/apt1-pla-61398",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Multi-year economic espionage campaign attributed by Mandiant to People's Liberation Army Unit 61398 (Second Bureau of the Third Department, General Staff Department), targeting at least 141 organisations across 20…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "China",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "APT1",
     "Comment Crew",
     "Comment Group",
     "Byzantine Candor"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "technology",
     "defense",
     "energy",
     "manufacturing",
     "telecommunications"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US",
     "CA",
     "GB",
     "KR",
     "JP",
     "TW"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0006"
    ],
    "organ": "PLA Unit 61398",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:salt-typhoon",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Salt Typhoon, US Telecommunications Backbone Compromise",
   "date": "Access established earlier; disclosed September–December 2024 (note: investigation and disclosures ongoing as of May 2025)",
   "year": 2024,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/salt-typhoon",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "China-linked intrusion campaign against US telecommunications operators including AT&T, Verizon, Lumen, and others, gaining access to portions of the carriers' core network infrastructure including, in some operators,…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "China",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "Salt Typhoon",
     "Earth Estries"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "telecommunications",
     "critical-infrastructure",
     "government"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US"
    ],
    "geographicScope": "allied-jurisdictions",
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G1045"
    ],
    "organ": "MSS",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:flame-flamer",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Flame / Flamer",
   "date": "Active circa 2007 – disclosed May 2012",
   "year": 2012,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/flame-flamer",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Modular espionage toolkit of exceptional size and sophistication disclosed in May 2012, primarily affecting computers in Iran, Israel/Palestine, Sudan, Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt. Flame collected…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "United States / Israel",
    "attributionConfidence": "moderate",
    "aliases": [
     "Flame",
     "Flamer",
     "sKyWIper"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "government",
     "education",
     "energy"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "IR",
     "IL",
     "SD",
     "SY",
     "LB",
     "SA",
     "EG"
    ],
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "cyber",
   "type": "case",
   "label": "Cloud Hopper / APT10 Managed Service Provider Campaign",
   "date": "Active circa 2014 – publicly disclosed April 2017; indictment December 2018",
   "year": 2018,
   "url": "https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app/cases/cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Multi-year campaign of intrusions against managed IT service providers (MSPs) in at least a dozen countries, pivoting through MSP credentials and infrastructure to reach the providers' downstream client networks. PwC…",
   "fields": {
    "incidentType": "espionage",
    "attributionCountry": "China",
    "attributionConfidence": "confirmed",
    "aliases": [
     "APT10",
     "Stone Panda",
     "MenuPass",
     "POTASSIUM",
     "Red Apollo"
    ],
    "targetSectors": [
     "technology",
     "telecommunications",
     "manufacturing",
     "finance",
     "healthcare",
     "government"
    ],
    "targetCountries": [
     "US",
     "GB",
     "JP",
     "AU",
     "CA",
     "FR",
     "DE",
     "NL",
     "SE",
     "CH",
     "BR",
     "IN",
     "KR"
    ],
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0045"
    ],
    "organ": "MSS (Tianjin State Security Bureau)",
    "targetEntities": []
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:1",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "China Lasers US Reconnaissance Satellite",
   "date": "2006-09-01",
   "year": 2006,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/1",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "China reportedly directed ground-based laser illumination at a US NRO reconnaissance satellite, temporarily blinding its imaging sensors. The US protested privately; China denied the incidents. Notable as an early…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "China",
    "type": "dazzling",
    "subtype": "Ground-based laser illumination",
    "target": "US NRO reconnaissance satellite (LEO)",
    "targetOperator": "US National Reconnaissance Office",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "medium",
    "severity": "medium"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:2",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "China FY-1C ASAT Test",
   "date": "2007-01-11",
   "year": 2007,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/2",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "China destroyed its own Fengyun-1C weather satellite using a ground-based SC-19 ASAT missile, creating the largest orbital debris event in history — over 3,500 trackable fragments. The US, UK, Japan, Canada, and…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "China",
    "type": "asat",
    "subtype": "Direct-ascent kinetic energy (SC-19)",
    "target": "Fengyun-1C (Chinese weather satellite, LEO 865 km)",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "critical"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:3",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "USA Operation Burnt Frost",
   "date": "2008-02-21",
   "year": 2008,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/3",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "The US Navy destroyed failed reconnaissance satellite USA-193 using a modified SM-3 missile from USS Lake Erie. The official justification was a hazardous hydrazine fuel tank. Critics noted the action also served as an…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "United States",
    "type": "asat",
    "subtype": "Sea-based SM-3 interceptor (modified)",
    "target": "USA-193 (failed NRO satellite, LEO ~250 km)",
    "targetOperator": "US National Reconnaissance Office",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:4",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "China SJ-12 Proximity to SJ-06F",
   "date": "2010-08-19",
   "year": 2010,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/4",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "China's Shijian-12 satellite conducted proximity maneuvers near Shijian-6F in LEO. Independent orbital mechanics analysis (Brian Weeden, SWF) suggested a possible deliberate close approach or contact. China did not…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "China",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Close approach / possible physical contact",
    "target": "Shijian-6F (Chinese satellite, LEO)",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "medium",
    "severity": "medium"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:5",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Iran RQ-170 Sentinel GPS Spoofing Capture",
   "date": "2011-12-04",
   "year": 2011,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/5",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Iran displayed an apparently intact US RQ-170 stealth drone, claiming capture via GPS spoofing that caused it to land at an Iranian airbase. Iran's EW unit stated it jammed the drone's communications and overrode its…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Iran",
    "type": "spoofing",
    "subtype": "UAV GPS navigation spoofing",
    "target": "US RQ-170 Sentinel UAV (CIA/USAF)",
    "targetOperator": "CIA / US Air Force",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "medium",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:6",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "North Korea GPS Jamming Campaign (2012)",
   "date": "2012-04-28",
   "year": 2012,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/6",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "North Korea conducted GPS jamming from DMZ-adjacent sites, disrupting approximately 1,016 aircraft and 254 ships over 16 days. South Korea's KCC documented the interference in detail. The campaign demonstrated North…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "North Korea",
    "type": "jamming",
    "subtype": "GPS L1/L2 jamming from ground-based transmitters",
    "target": "South Korean aviation, shipping, military communications",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:7",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "China Shiyan-7 Grappling Arm Demonstration",
   "date": "2013-07-20",
   "year": 2013,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/7",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "China launched Shijian-7 carrying a robotic grappling arm and conducted RPO with other Chinese satellites. Officially a debris removal demonstrator, the capability is dual-use — directly applicable to grappling…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "China",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Grappling arm proximity operation",
    "target": "Shijian-7 / Chuangxin-1-03 (Chinese satellites, LEO)",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "high",
    "severity": "medium"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:8",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Cosmos-2499 Proximity Operations",
   "date": "2014-05-23",
   "year": 2014,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/8",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Russia launched Cosmos-2499 covertly alongside a Rokot commercial payload and never officially described it. TLE analysis by independent trackers confirmed sustained RPO activity over many months, with the satellite…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Maneuvering inspector satellite",
    "target": "Multiple Russian satellites (LEO)",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "high",
    "severity": "medium"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:9",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Luch/Olymp-K GEO Proximity Operation",
   "date": "2015-04-08",
   "year": 2015,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/9",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Russia's Luch/Olymp-K satellite maneuvered to sit between two Intelsat GEO satellites for several months. Never officially acknowledged by Russia. The proximity raised concerns about signal interception, spectrum…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Sustained co-orbital proximity in GEO",
    "target": "Intelsat 7 / IS-901 commercial satellite (GEO ~13°E)",
    "targetOperator": "Intelsat",
    "orbit": "GEO",
    "confidence": "high",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:10",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Turla APT Satellite Communication Hijacking",
   "date": "2015-09-01",
   "year": 2015,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/10",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Kaspersky Lab and Symantec documented Russia's Turla APT using commercial satellite internet downlinks as C2 infrastructure, intercepting unencrypted traffic and spoofing subscriber IP ranges. The technique made…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia (attributed: FSB Turla APT)",
    "actorOrg": "FSB",
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0010"
    ],
    "type": "cyber",
    "subtype": "Satellite downlink hijacking for C2 infrastructure",
    "cyberVector": "Satellite downlink hijacking for command-and-control",
    "target": "Commercial satellite internet links (multiple countries)",
    "orbit": "GEO",
    "confidence": "high",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:11",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "North Korea GPS Jamming Campaign (2016)",
   "date": "2016-04-01",
   "year": 2016,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/11",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "North Korea conducted its largest GPS jamming campaign on record, affecting approximately 962 aircraft and 700+ fishing vessels over 36 days. South Korea's KCC traced and documented the interference comprehensively.…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "North Korea",
    "type": "jamming",
    "subtype": "Sustained multi-band GPS jamming",
    "target": "South Korean aviation, shipping, military (36-day campaign)",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:12",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "China SJ-17 GEO Proximity Operations",
   "date": "2016-10-25",
   "year": 2016,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/12",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "China's SJ-17 experimental satellite was launched into GEO and conducted extended proximity operations near other Chinese GEO satellites. SJ-17 carried a robotic arm. SWF analysts noted it as China's most capable RPO…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "China",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "GEO servicing / inspection demonstrator",
    "target": "ChinaSat-20 / DFH-4 class satellite (GEO ~105°E)",
    "orbit": "GEO",
    "confidence": "high",
    "severity": "medium"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:13",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Black Sea GNSS Spoofing Incidents",
   "date": "2017-06-22",
   "year": 2017,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/13",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Over 20 ships in the Black Sea reported AIS/GPS discrepancies showing their positions inland (near Gelendzhik Airport) while at sea. Documented comprehensively by C4ADS in its landmark 2019 report 'Above Us Only…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "spoofing",
    "subtype": "GNSS position spoofing at maritime scale",
    "target": "Commercial shipping (20+ vessels), Black Sea / Azov Sea",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "high",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:14",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Cosmos-2521/2519 Matryoshka Satellite",
   "date": "2017-08-14",
   "year": 2017,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/14",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Russia's Cosmos-2521 ejected a sub-satellite (Cosmos-2523) which subsequently maneuvered. USSPACECOM issued a public statement noting the 'unusual behavior'. The 'nesting doll' architecture — a satellite releasing a…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Object ejection from maneuvering satellite",
    "target": "LEO-MEO orbital belt",
    "orbit": "MEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:15",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Baltic / Nordic GNSS Jamming",
   "date": "2018-10-25",
   "year": 2018,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/15",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Extensive GPS signal jamming was observed over Finland, Norway, and Baltic states coinciding with NATO Trident Juncture 2018 and Russian Vostok-2018 exercises. EASA issued Safety Information Bulletin 2019-02. Finland's…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "jamming",
    "subtype": "GPS L1 jamming during military exercises",
    "target": "Commercial aviation, NATO exercises (Finland, Norway, Estonia, Latvia)",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:16",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "India Mission Shakti ASAT Test",
   "date": "2019-03-27",
   "year": 2019,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/16",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "India conducted its first ASAT test, destroying Microsat-R at ~283 km altitude using a Prithvi Defence Vehicle Mk-II. PM Modi announced it publicly, making India the fourth ASAT-capable nation. The low altitude was…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "India",
    "type": "asat",
    "subtype": "Direct-ascent kinetic energy (PDV Mk II)",
    "target": "Microsat-R (Indian DRDO test satellite, LEO ~283 km)",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:17",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Cosmos-2542/2543 'Nesting Doll' Inspector",
   "date": "2019-11-25",
   "year": 2019,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/17",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Cosmos-2542 launched in November 2019 and immediately deployed Cosmos-2543 as a sub-satellite. Both tracked USA-245, a US NRO reconnaissance satellite. USSPACECOM publicly warned Russia in January 2020. The State Dept…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Inspector satellite tracking US national security asset",
    "target": "USA-245 (US NRO KH-11 reconnaissance satellite, LEO)",
    "targetOperator": "US National Reconnaissance Office",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:18",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Shanghai / East China Sea GPS Spoofing",
   "date": "2019-08-01",
   "year": 2019,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/18",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Vessels near Shanghai reported systematic GPS spoofing showing their positions on land or in circular patterns. Attributed to ground-based counter-drone infrastructure protecting sensitive facilities, with civilian…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Unknown (attributed: China, counter-drone infrastructure)",
    "type": "spoofing",
    "subtype": "Maritime GPS position spoofing",
    "target": "Commercial shipping, Huangpu River / East China Sea",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "medium",
    "severity": "medium"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:19",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Cosmos 2543 Object Release (Space-Based ASAT Test)",
   "date": "2020-07-15",
   "year": 2020,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/19",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "On 15 July 2020 Russia's inspector satellite Cosmos 2543 released a high-speed object near another Russian satellite, according to USSPACECOM, which called it further evidence of Russia's space-based anti-satellite…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Object released from an inspector satellite",
    "target": "Near another Russian satellite (LEO)",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:20",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Nudol ASAT Test / Kosmos-1408",
   "date": "2021-11-15",
   "year": 2021,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/20",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Russia destroyed its defunct Kosmos-1408 satellite using a PL-19 Nudol ASAT, creating ~1,500 trackable fragments threatening the International Space Station. ISS crew sheltered in docked vehicles. The US, UK, EU,…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "asat",
    "subtype": "Direct-ascent kinetic energy (PL-19 Nudol)",
    "target": "Kosmos-1408 (defunct Tselina-D SIGINT satellite, LEO ~480 km)",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "critical"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:21",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Viasat KA-SAT AcidRain Cyberattack",
   "date": "2022-02-24",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/21",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Hours before Russia's invasion of Ukraine, GRU Sandworm deployed 'AcidRain' wiper malware against Viasat's KA-SAT network, permanently disabling ~40,000 modems across Ukraine and Europe. Ukrainian military…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia (GRU Sandworm)",
    "actorOrg": "GRU",
    "intrusionSetIds": [
     "G0034"
    ],
    "type": "cyber",
    "subtype": "Satellite ground-segment wiper malware (AcidRain)",
    "cyberVector": "Ground-segment compromise and wiper malware against user modems",
    "malwareFamilies": [
     "AcidRain"
    ],
    "target": "Viasat KA-SAT network (Ukraine + ~40,000 modems across Europe)",
    "targetOperator": "Viasat",
    "orbit": "GEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "critical"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:22",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Starlink Jamming in Ukraine",
   "date": "2022-03-05",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/22",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Russia jammed SpaceX Starlink terminals deployed in Ukraine, disrupting the communications lifeline on which Ukrainian forces depended. SpaceX CEO Elon Musk publicly acknowledged the jamming and stated engineers…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "jamming",
    "subtype": "Satellite terminal uplink jamming",
    "target": "SpaceX Starlink terminals (Ukrainian military and civilian users)",
    "targetOperator": "SpaceX (Starlink)",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:23",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Systematic GNSS EW — Ukraine & NATO Airspace",
   "date": "2022-03-10",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/23",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Russia deployed large-scale EW including GPS/GNSS jamming throughout eastern Ukraine and adjacent NATO airspace. Commercial aviation across Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and Poland reported GPS signal loss on…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "jamming",
    "subtype": "Multi-system GNSS EW (Krasukha-4, Pole-21, Murmansk-BN)",
    "target": "Ukraine military, NATO civilian aviation (Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland)",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:24",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Cosmos-2558 Shadows US Spy Satellite",
   "date": "2022-08-04",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/24",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Russia launched Cosmos-2558 on 1 August 2022; within days USSPACECOM confirmed it was tracking USA-326, a US Space Force reconnaissance satellite. US officials publicly called out the behavior. The most direct…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Inspector satellite tracking US national security asset",
    "target": "USA-326 (US Space Force reconnaissance satellite, LEO)",
    "targetOperator": "US Space Force",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:25",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Middle East GPS Spoofing Escalation",
   "date": "2023-06-01",
   "year": 2023,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/25",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Beginning mid-2023 and intensifying after October 2023, OPSGROUP, EASA, and safety organizations documented widespread GPS spoofing across the Eastern Mediterranean, Middle East, and Red Sea. Dozens of airline flights…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Multiple (attributed: Israel IDF, contested)",
    "actorOrg": "IDF (attribution contested)",
    "type": "spoofing",
    "subtype": "Large-scale airspace GPS spoofing",
    "target": "Commercial aviation — Eastern Mediterranean, Middle East, Red Sea",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "medium",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:26",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "China SJ-21 GEO Satellite Tow Operation",
   "date": "2022-01-26",
   "year": 2022,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/26",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "China's SJ-21 conducted a rendezvous with the aged Beidou Compass-G2 satellite and towed it to a higher graveyard orbit — the first confirmed satellite tow in GEO. Framed as debris management, but the demonstrated…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "China",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Satellite towing / grapple-and-relocate in GEO",
    "target": "Compass-G2 / Beidou navigation satellite (GEO graveyard orbit)",
    "orbit": "GEO",
    "confidence": "high",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:27",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Russia Cosmos-2576 RPO near US Spy Satellite",
   "date": "2024-05-22",
   "year": 2024,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/27",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "Russia launched Cosmos-2576 on 16 May 2024 into the same orbital plane as USA-314. USSPACECOM issued a public statement on 22 May confirming it was tracking USA-314 as an 'inspector'. The most recent in Russia's…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Russia",
    "type": "proximity",
    "subtype": "Inspector satellite co-orbital RPO",
    "target": "USA-314 (US Space Force reconnaissance satellite, LEO ~480 km)",
    "targetOperator": "US Space Force",
    "orbit": "LEO",
    "confidence": "confirmed",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:28",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "type": "incident",
   "label": "Global GPS Spoofing Escalation (2024)",
   "date": "2024-01-01",
   "year": 2024,
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/28",
   "urlPrecision": "record",
   "summary": "OPSGROUP's 2024 review documented a dramatic escalation in GPS spoofing globally, with pilots reporting navigation system failures on thousands of flights. Affected regions included Poland/Baltic (Russia), Middle East…",
   "fields": {
    "actor": "Multiple state actors",
    "type": "spoofing",
    "subtype": "Multi-region, multi-actor airspace GPS spoofing",
    "target": "Commercial aviation — Eastern Europe, Middle East, East Asia",
    "orbit": "N/A",
    "confidence": "high",
    "severity": "high"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-palo-verde",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station",
   "date": "1986",
   "year": 1986,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Largest US nuclear station by net output. Uses reclaimed municipal wastewater for cooling — unique globally. Three CE System 80 PWR units.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (CE System 80)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-vogtle",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Vogtle Electric Generating Plant",
   "date": "1987",
   "year": 1987,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Units 1–2 operating since late 1980s. Units 3–4 (AP1000, first new US reactors in 30+ years) achieved commercial operation in 2023–2024.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (AP1000 Units 3–4; WH Units 1–2)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-south-texas",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "South Texas Project",
   "date": "1988",
   "year": 1988,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit CE pressurized water reactor station on the Gulf Coast of Texas.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (CE)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-diablo-canyon",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Diablo Canyon Power Plant",
   "date": "1985",
   "year": 1985,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "California's only operating nuclear station. Lifetime extended after initial plans for closure were reversed under state energy policy.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-peach-bottom",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station",
   "date": "1974",
   "year": 1974,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit GE boiling water reactor station in southern Pennsylvania.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (GE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-braidwood",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Braidwood Generating Station",
   "date": "1988",
   "year": 1988,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit Westinghouse PWR station in northeastern Illinois.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-comanche-peak",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1990",
   "year": 1990,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit PWR station in north-central Texas supplying the ERCOT grid.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-watts-bar",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Watts Bar Nuclear Plant",
   "date": "1996",
   "year": 1996,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "TVA-owned two-unit plant. Unit 2 (2016) was the first new US commercial reactor since 1996. Unit 1 produces tritium for the US government.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-browns-ferry",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant",
   "date": "1974",
   "year": 1974,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Three-unit GE BWR station in northern Alabama. At the time of its completion, was the world's largest nuclear station by capacity.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (GE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-calvert-cliffs",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1975",
   "year": 1975,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit CE PWR station on Chesapeake Bay, Maryland. One of the longest-operating plants in the US.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (CE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-seabrook",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Seabrook Station",
   "date": "1990",
   "year": 1990,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Single-unit Westinghouse PWR in New Hampshire. Supplies a significant share of New England's electricity.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-millstone",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Millstone Power Station",
   "date": "1975",
   "year": 1975,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Connecticut's only nuclear station; two operating units. Millstone Unit 1 (BWR) permanently shut 1998.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Combustion Engineering)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-north-anna",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "North Anna Power Station",
   "date": "1978",
   "year": 1978,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit Westinghouse PWR station in central Virginia.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-oconee",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Oconee Nuclear Station",
   "date": "1973",
   "year": 1973,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Three-unit Babcock & Wilcox PWR station in South Carolina, one of the most efficient US nuclear stations.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (B&W)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-grand-gulf",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Grand Gulf Nuclear Station",
   "date": "1985",
   "year": 1985,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Single-unit GE BWR, one of the largest single-unit BWR stations in the US.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (GE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-turkey-point",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station",
   "date": "1972",
   "year": 1972,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit Westinghouse PWR station south of Miami, Florida. NRC approved license extension to 80 years.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-columbia",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Columbia Generating Station",
   "date": "1984",
   "year": 1984,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Washington state's only commercial nuclear plant; BWR supplying Pacific Northwest grid.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (GE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-indian-point",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Indian Point Energy Center",
   "date": "1962",
   "year": 1962,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Indian Point Units 2 and 3 permanently shut in 2021. Site in decommissioning. Historically supplied ~25% of New York City metropolitan area electricity.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "shutdown",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-three-mile-island",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Three Mile Island (Crane Clean Energy Center)",
   "date": "1974",
   "year": 1974,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "TMI Unit 1 restarted September 2023 under a PPA with Microsoft. TMI Unit 2 (1979 accident unit) remains in SAFSTOR decommissioning.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (B&W)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:us-san-onofre",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station",
   "date": "1968",
   "year": 1968,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Units 2 and 3 permanently shut in 2013 following steam generator tube degradation issues. Full decommissioning underway.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "status": "shutdown",
    "reactorType": "PWR (CE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:fr-gravelines",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Gravelines Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1980",
   "year": 1980,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Largest nuclear power plant in Western Europe by capacity. Six 900 MWe PWR units on the English Channel coast.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "France",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (900 MWe class)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State + EURATOM"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:fr-cattenom",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Cattenom Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1986",
   "year": 1986,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four-unit 1300 MWe PWR station near the borders of Luxembourg, Germany, and Belgium.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "France",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (1300 MWe class)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State + EURATOM"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:fr-paluel",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Paluel Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1985",
   "year": 1985,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four-unit 1300 MWe PWR station on the Normandy coast.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "France",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (1300 MWe class)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State + EURATOM"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:fr-flamanville",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Flamanville Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1986",
   "year": 1986,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Units 1–2 (1300 MWe) operating. Unit 3 is the Flamanville 3 EPR — Europe's second Generation III+ reactor, entering commercial operation ca. 2024 after significant delays.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "France",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (1300 MWe) + EPR (Unit 3)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State + EURATOM"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:fr-chinon",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Chinon Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1983",
   "year": 1983,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four 900 MWe PWR units on the Loire River in Indre-et-Loire.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "France",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (900 MWe class)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State + EURATOM"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:fr-blayais",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Blayais Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1981",
   "year": 1981,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four 900 MWe PWR units on the Gironde estuary.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "France",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (900 MWe class)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State + EURATOM"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:cn-qinshan",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Qinshan Nuclear Power Base",
   "date": "1991",
   "year": 1991,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "China's first domestically designed commercial nuclear station and a multi-unit complex with nine units of various reactor types. Includes China's only CANDU-6 reactors.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "China",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR / CANDU / CNP (multiple types)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:cn-daya-bay",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Daya Bay / Ling Ao Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1994",
   "year": 1994,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "China's first large-scale commercial nuclear station; joint development with France. Supplies electricity to Guangdong and Hong Kong.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "China",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (M310 / ACPR-1000)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:cn-tianwan",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Tianwan Nuclear Power Station",
   "date": "2007",
   "year": 2007,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Six Russian-designed VVER reactor units in Jiangsu. Additional units under construction. One of the largest nuclear sites in China.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "China",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1000 / VVER-1200",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:cn-hongyanhe",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Hongyanhe Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "2013",
   "year": 2013,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Six-unit ACPR-1000 pressurized water reactor station in Liaoning Province — northeastern China.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "China",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (ACPR-1000)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:cn-yangjiang",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Yangjiang Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "2014",
   "year": 2014,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Six-unit station in Guangdong Province, all CPR/ACPR-1000 type.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "China",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (CPR-1000 / ACPR-1000)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:cn-taishan",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Taishan Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "2018",
   "year": 2018,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "World's first operational EPR reactors. Two units of the European Pressurized Reactor design in Guangdong Province.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "China",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "EPR (1750 MWe)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ru-balakovo",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Balakovo Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1985",
   "year": 1985,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four-unit VVER-1000 station in the Saratov region. Russia's most productive nuclear power plant by annual generation.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Russia",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ru-leningrad",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Leningrad Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1973",
   "year": 1973,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Historic site supplying St. Petersburg. Original RBMK units being phased out; new VVER-1200 units (Leningrad II) have commenced operation.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Russia",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "RBMK-1000 (Units 1–2, being decommissioned) / VVER-1200 (Units 3–4)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ru-kalinin",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Kalinin Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1984",
   "year": 1984,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four-unit VVER-1000 station in Tver Oblast, supplying Moscow and surrounding regions.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Russia",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ru-smolensk",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Smolensk Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1982",
   "year": 1982,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Three-unit RBMK-1000 station. Same channel reactor type as Chernobyl; design substantially modified after 1986.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Russia",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "RBMK-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ru-beloyarsk",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Beloyarsk Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1964",
   "year": 1964,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Home to Russia's BN-800 commercial fast neutron reactor — one of the world's few operating fast reactors. Historically significant in fast reactor development.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Russia",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BN-800 Fast Neutron / AMB (shutdown) / BN-1200 (planned)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:kr-kori",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Kori / Shin-Kori Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1978",
   "year": 1978,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Largest nuclear station cluster in South Korea. Kori Unit 1 (1978) permanently shutdown 2017 — the first decommissioned Korean reactor. Shin-Kori includes new APR-1400 units.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "South Korea",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (various – OPR-1000, APR-1400, WH)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": true,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/236)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:kr-hanul",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Hanul Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1988",
   "year": 1988,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Six-unit station in North Gyeongsang Province. Mix of OPR-1000 and APR-1400 units.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "South Korea",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (OPR-1000 / APR-1400)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/236)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:kr-hanbit",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Hanbit Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1986",
   "year": 1986,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Six-unit Westinghouse/OPR-1000 station on the Yellow Sea coast of South Jeolla Province.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "South Korea",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (WH / OPR-1000)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/236)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ca-bruce",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Bruce Nuclear Generating Station",
   "date": "1977",
   "year": 1977,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "World's largest operating nuclear station by total capacity. Eight CANDU units on eastern Lake Huron shore.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Canada",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "CANDU (PHWR)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/164)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ca-darlington",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Darlington Nuclear Generating Station",
   "date": "1990",
   "year": 1990,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four-unit CANDU station east of Toronto. Major life-extension refurbishment underway. OPG also constructing SMR demonstration units on-site.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Canada",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "CANDU (PHWR)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/164)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ca-pickering",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Pickering Nuclear Generating Station",
   "date": "1971",
   "year": 1971,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Six-unit CANDU station east of Toronto. Four units in operation; two permanently shut. Operational life extended to support grid reliability.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Canada",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "CANDU (PHWR)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/164)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:gb-sizewell-b",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Sizewell B Nuclear Power Station",
   "date": "1995",
   "year": 1995,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "UK's only operational PWR. EDF Energy operates the station; lifetime extension under discussion.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United Kingdom",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:gb-heysham",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Heysham Nuclear Power Station",
   "date": "1983",
   "year": 1983,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two separate AGR stations (Heysham 1 and 2) on the Lancashire coast. AGRs use carbon dioxide coolant and graphite moderator.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United Kingdom",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "AGR (Advanced Gas-cooled Reactor)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:gb-torness",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Torness Nuclear Power Station",
   "date": "1988",
   "year": 1988,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit AGR station on the Scottish coast; one of Scotland's two nuclear stations.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United Kingdom",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "AGR",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:gb-hinkley-c",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Hinkley Point C",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two-unit EPR plant under construction in Somerset. First new UK nuclear station in decades; expected online mid-2020s. Subject to significant cost and schedule revisions.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United Kingdom",
    "status": "under_construction",
    "reactorType": "EPR (1600 MWe)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Voluntary Offer Agreement (VOA) - NPT Weapon State"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:jp-sendai",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Sendai Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1984",
   "year": 1984,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "First Japanese plant to restart after post-Fukushima new regulatory framework (2015). Two Mitsubishi PWR units in Kagoshima Prefecture.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Japan",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Mitsubishi)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/255)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:jp-genkai",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Genkai Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1975",
   "year": 1975,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two active units restarted under NRA post-Fukushima safety framework. Units 1–2 permanently shutdown.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Japan",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Mitsubishi / Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/255)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:jp-takahama",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Takahama Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1974",
   "year": 1974,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four-unit PWR in Fukui Prefecture. Units 3–4 have restarted; Units 1–2 among first old plants approved for 60-year operation.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Japan",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Mitsubishi)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/255)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:jp-fukushima-daini",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Fukushima Daini Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1982",
   "year": 1982,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Fukushima Daini (No. 2) plant, 12 km south of Fukushima Daiichi. All 4 units permanently shut down; decommissioning decided in 2019.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Japan",
    "status": "shutdown",
    "reactorType": "BWR (GE / Toshiba)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/255)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:in-kudankulam",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "2013",
   "year": 2013,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two operating VVER-1000 units (Russian design) in Tamil Nadu. Additional units under construction. India's largest single nuclear station.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "India",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Facility-specific safeguards (India-IAEA Agreement, INFCIRC/754)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:in-tarapur",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Tarapur Atomic Power Station",
   "date": "1969",
   "year": 1969,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "India's first commercial nuclear station. Units 1–2 are original GE BWRs (1969); Units 3–4 are PHWR designs.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "India",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (Units 1–2) / PHWR (Units 3–4)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Facility-specific safeguards (India-IAEA Agreement, INFCIRC/754)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:in-rajasthan",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Rajasthan Atomic Power Station",
   "date": "1973",
   "year": 1973,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Six PHWR units in Rajasthan. India's nuclear programme uses domestically evolved PHWR technology derived from early Canadian CANDU collaboration.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "India",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PHWR (CANDU-derived)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Facility-specific safeguards (India-IAEA Agreement, INFCIRC/754)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ua-zaporizhzhia",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1984",
   "year": 1984,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Europe's largest nuclear station. All six units in cold shutdown since 2022 due to conflict conditions. IAEA expert presence maintained. Publicly documented through regular IAEA reports.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Ukraine",
    "status": "suspended",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/550)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ua-rivne",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Rivne Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1980",
   "year": 1980,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four-unit mixed VVER station in western Ukraine. Operating as of latest public reporting.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Ukraine",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-440 / VVER-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/550)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ua-south-ukraine",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "South Ukraine Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1982",
   "year": 1982,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Three-unit VVER-1000 station in Mykolaiv Oblast. Operating as of latest public reporting.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Ukraine",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/550)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:fi-olkiluoto",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Olkiluoto Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1978",
   "year": 1978,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "OL3 (EPR, 1600 MWe) began commercial operation April 2023 — first new reactor in Western Europe in ~16 years and world's most powerful single reactor unit.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Finland",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (Units 1–2) / EPR (Unit 3)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:fi-loviisa",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Loviisa Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1977",
   "year": 1977,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two VVER-440 units on the Gulf of Finland coast. Finnish-modified Soviet design with western safety upgrades.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Finland",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-440",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:se-forsmark",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Forsmark Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1980",
   "year": 1980,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Three-unit ABB BWR station in Uppsala County. One of Europe's most efficient nuclear stations.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Sweden",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (ABB Atom)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:se-ringhals",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Ringhals Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1975",
   "year": 1975,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two units operating (Ringhals 3 and 4, PWR). Units 1 and 2 permanently shut 2019–2020.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Sweden",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR / BWR",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:be-doel",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Doel Nuclear Power Station",
   "date": "1975",
   "year": 1975,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Three active PWR units near Antwerp. Belgium decided to extend Doel 4 operation to 2035 and pursue lifetime extension for Doel 3.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Belgium",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:be-tihange",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Tihange Nuclear Power Station",
   "date": "1975",
   "year": 1975,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two operating PWR units on the Meuse River. Belgium extended Tihange 3 to 2035; Tihange 1–2 operational life decisions ongoing.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Belgium",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse / Framatome)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:cz-dukovany",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Dukovany Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1985",
   "year": 1985,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four VVER-440 units, significantly modernised. ČEZ planning new unit construction adjacent to existing site.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Czech Republic",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-440",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:cz-temelin",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Temelín Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "2002",
   "year": 2002,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two VVER-1000 units with Western instrumentation and control systems. South Bohemia.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Czech Republic",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:hu-paks",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Paks Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1982",
   "year": 1982,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Four VVER-440 units supplying ~50% of Hungary's electricity. Life extension approved. Paks II (new units) in planning/permitting.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Hungary",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-440",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:es-almaraz",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Almaraz Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1981",
   "year": 1981,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Spain's largest nuclear station. Operational life extended; scheduled shutdown under Spain's national energy plan.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Spain",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:es-cofrentes",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Cofrentes Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1984",
   "year": 1984,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Spain's only BWR. Single-unit GE BWR in Valencia region.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Spain",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (GE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ch-leibstadt",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Leibstadt Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1984",
   "year": 1984,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Switzerland's newest and most powerful nuclear station. Single-unit GE BWR.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Switzerland",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (GE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/264)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ch-beznau",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Beznau Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1969",
   "year": 1969,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "World's oldest operating commercial nuclear power plant (Unit 1 since 1969). Two Westinghouse PWR units.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Switzerland",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/264)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:de-isar",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Isar 2 (Kernkraftwerk Isar 2)",
   "date": "1988",
   "year": 1988,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Permanently shut 15 April 2023 — one of the last three German nuclear plants to close under Germany's Atomausstieg (nuclear phase-out) policy.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Germany",
    "status": "shutdown",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Siemens)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:nl-borssele",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Borssele Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1973",
   "year": 1973,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Netherlands' only operating nuclear station. Lifetime extended. Government planning at least two new large reactors.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Netherlands",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Siemens/KWU)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ae-barakah",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Barakah Nuclear Energy Plant",
   "date": "2020",
   "year": 2020,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "First nuclear power plant in the Arab world. Four APR-1400 units. Units 1–3 in commercial operation; Unit 4 commissioning. Developed with Korean technology by KEPCO.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United Arab Emirates",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "APR-1400 (PWR)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/622)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ar-atucha",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Atucha Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1974",
   "year": 1974,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Argentina's flagship nuclear site. Atucha I (1974) was Latin America's first commercial nuclear plant. Atucha II joined commercial operation in 2014.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Argentina",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PHWR (Siemens PHWR)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA (INFCIRC/435) - Quadripartite Agreement with ABACC; no Additional Protocol"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:br-angra",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Angra Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1982",
   "year": 1982,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two PWR units in Rio de Janeiro State. Angra 3 under construction (delayed). Brazil's only commercial nuclear station.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Brazil",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse / Siemens-KWU)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA (INFCIRC/435) - Quadripartite Agreement with ABACC"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:za-koeberg",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Koeberg Nuclear Power Station",
   "date": "1984",
   "year": 1984,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Africa's only commercial nuclear power station. Two French Framatome PWR units north of Cape Town. 20-year life extension approved.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "South Africa",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Framatome)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/394)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:pk-kanupp",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Karachi Nuclear Power Plant (KANUPP)",
   "date": "1971",
   "year": 1971,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Pakistan's primary civilian nuclear station. KANUPP-1 (1971, now shutdown). KANUPP-2 and KANUPP-3 (Hualong One, Chinese-supplied) in operation as of 2021–2022.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Pakistan",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PHWR (CANDU-derived) / PWR (Hualong One)",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "Facility-specific safeguards (INFCIRC/393)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ir-bushehr",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Bushehr Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "2011",
   "year": 2011,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Iran's only commercial nuclear power plant. VVER-1000 built with Russian assistance. Unit 2 under construction. Operates under IAEA safeguards.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Iran",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1000",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA (INFCIRC/214) - Additional Protocol signed but not ratified"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:mx-laguna-verde",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Laguna Verde Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1990",
   "year": 1990,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Mexico's only nuclear plant. Two GE BWR units in Veracruz. Provides ~4% of Mexico's electricity.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Mexico",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "BWR (GE)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/197)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:ro-cernavoda",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Cernavodă Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1996",
   "year": 1996,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Two CANDU-6 units on the Danube. Provides ~20% of Romania's electricity. Units 3–5 in long-term planning.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Romania",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "CANDU-6 (PHWR)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:si-krsko",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Krško Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "1983",
   "year": 1983,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Jointly owned and operated by Slovenia and Croatia. Single Westinghouse PWR supplying both national grids.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Slovenia",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "PWR (Westinghouse)",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "EURATOM + IAEA (INFCIRC/193)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:am-metsamor",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Armenian Nuclear Power Plant (Metsamor)",
   "date": "1976",
   "year": 1976,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "One of the older VVER-440 designs still in operation. Provides a significant share of Armenia's electricity. Life extension underway.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Armenia",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-440",
    "digitalIandC": false,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/455)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:by-ostrovets",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Ostrovets Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": "2021",
   "year": 2021,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Belarus's first and only nuclear power plant. Two VVER-1200 units built by Rosatom. Unit 1 in commercial operation since 2021; Unit 2 from 2023.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Belarus",
    "status": "operating",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1200",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA - Additional Protocol signed 2005, not in force"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:bd-rooppur",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Rooppur Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Bangladesh's first nuclear power plant, built with Russian assistance. Two VVER-1200 units. Expected to begin operation in the 2020s.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Bangladesh",
    "status": "under_construction",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1200",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:tr-akkuyu",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "Akkuyu Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Turkey's first nuclear plant, built on a BOO (Build-Own-Operate) model by Rosatom. Four VVER-1200 units. Construction ongoing.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Turkey",
    "status": "under_construction",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1200",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": false,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA + Additional Protocol (INFCIRC/295)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear:eg-el-dabaa",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "type": "plant",
   "label": "El-Dabaa Nuclear Power Plant",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app/infrastructure",
   "urlPrecision": "page",
   "summary": "Egypt's first nuclear plant, four VVER-1200 units. Construction underway on the Mediterranean coast.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Egypt",
    "status": "under_construction",
    "reactorType": "VVER-1200",
    "digitalIandC": true,
    "reportedCyberIncident": false,
    "criticalInfrastructureOverlap": true,
    "safeguardsStatus": "CSA (INFCIRC/302)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-001",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Due Regard (Outer Space Treaty)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "No external arbiter determines what constitutes \"due regard.\" Each spacefaring state defines the threshold of consideration owed to others, creating asymmetric obligation based on capability.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Due Regard",
    "document": "Outer Space Treaty",
    "documentIds": [
     "OST-1967"
    ],
    "section": "Article IX",
    "holder": "Each State Party (self-judging)",
    "coalition": "ost",
    "type": "open_ended_qualifier"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-002",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Harmful Interference (Artemis Accords)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Sets the boundary for deconfliction without a central judge. The drafting party retains interpretive control over what constitutes \"harmful\" activity near its operations.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Harmful Interference",
    "document": "Artemis Accords",
    "documentIds": [
     "AA-2020"
    ],
    "section": "Section 11, para. 4",
    "holder": "Each Signatory (self-judging)",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "type": "open_ended_qualifier"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-003",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Safety Zone (Artemis Accords)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Functional exclusion zones without treaty basis. The \"notifying\" state defines the perimeter, converting operational presence into territorial-adjacent authority.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Safety Zone",
    "document": "Artemis Accords",
    "documentIds": [
     "AA-2020"
    ],
    "section": "Section 11, para. 7",
    "holder": "Operating Signatory (sets and notifies the safety zone)",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "type": "procedural_deferral"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-004",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Co-consultation (China–Russia intergovernmental Memorandum of Understanding on the ILRS (9 March 2021))",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Consultation without voting rights. Joining partners are consulted but founding states retain architectural control over station design, location, and operational rules. The MoU itself is not public, so its terms…",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Co-consultation",
    "document": "China–Russia intergovernmental Memorandum of Understanding on the ILRS (9 March 2021)",
    "documentIds": [
     "ILRS-MOU-2021"
    ],
    "section": "MoU text not public; CNSA summary of 9 March 2021",
    "holder": "CNSA / Roscosmos (founding partners)",
    "coalition": "ilrs",
    "type": "procedural_deferral"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-005",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "All Interested International Partners (ILRS Guide for Partnership (V1.0, CNSA and Roscosmos))",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Open invitation framed by \"the interests of all humankind\" without defining who qualifies as a partner or how benefits are shared. The two founding agencies set the terms of partnership.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "All Interested International Partners",
    "document": "ILRS Guide for Partnership (V1.0, CNSA and Roscosmos)",
    "documentIds": [
     "ILRS-GUIDE-2023"
    ],
    "section": "Preface, p. 2",
    "holder": "CNSA / Roscosmos (joint authors and conveners)",
    "coalition": "ilrs",
    "type": "definitional_gap"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-006",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "National Interest (UAE Federal Law No. 12 of 2019 on the Regulation of the Space Sector)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Data sharing obligations yield to undefined \"national interest,\" creating a black-box override for transparency commitments. Unverified: the 2019 law text could not be read, and the law was repealed by Federal…",
   "fields": {
    "term": "National Interest",
    "document": "UAE Federal Law No. 12 of 2019 on the Regulation of the Space Sector",
    "documentIds": [
     "UAE-LAW-2019"
    ],
    "section": "Article 7 (as cited; not checked)",
    "holder": "UAE Space Agency",
    "coalition": "national",
    "type": "carve_out"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-007",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Peaceful Use (pacifist principles / national security) (Japan Basic Space Law)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "The Act, passed by the Diet, keeps outer space use \"in accordance with the pacifist principles of the Constitution\" (Art. 2) while directing the government to promote space use \"to contribute to Japan’s national…",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Peaceful Use (pacifist principles / national security)",
    "document": "Japan Basic Space Law",
    "documentIds": [
     "JP-BSL-2008"
    ],
    "section": "Article 2; see also Articles 3 and 14",
    "holder": "National Diet (statute, 2008); the Government in applying it",
    "coalition": "national",
    "type": "definitional_gap"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-008",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Space Resources Capable of Appropriation (Luxembourg Space Resources Law)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "The law states affirmatively that space resources can be appropriated, using the word that OST Article II applies to outer space and celestial bodies. It does not define \"space resources\" or where a resource ends and a…",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Space Resources Capable of Appropriation",
    "document": "Luxembourg Space Resources Law",
    "documentIds": [
     "LUX-SRL-2017"
    ],
    "section": "Article 1",
    "holder": "Luxembourg legislature; ministers for the economy and space activities (mission authorisation, Art. 2)",
    "coalition": "national",
    "type": "definitional_gap"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-009",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Licence Requirement (draft) (Draft Space Activities Bill, 2017 (India))",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Single gateway licensing concentrates authority over all commercial space activity involving Indian entities in the Central Government. This is a 2017 draft published for consultation, not enacted law.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Licence Requirement (draft)",
    "document": "Draft Space Activities Bill, 2017 (India)",
    "documentIds": [
     "IN-SAB-2023"
    ],
    "section": "Chapter III, section 6(1)",
    "holder": "Central Government (licensing authority under the draft)",
    "coalition": "national",
    "type": "procedural_deferral"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-010",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Lunar Time Standard (OSTP Coordinated Lunar Time (LTC) Framework)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Authority over reference frames. Whoever defines the time standard for cislunar space defines the coordination infrastructure all actors must adopt. The instrument is an OSTP policy memorandum to federal agencies, not…",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Lunar Time Standard",
    "document": "OSTP Coordinated Lunar Time (LTC) Framework",
    "documentIds": [
     "US-OSTP-LTC-2024"
    ],
    "section": "OSTP memorandum, Section 2(b)",
    "holder": "NASA (tasked by OSTP)",
    "coalition": "national",
    "type": "procedural_deferral"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-011",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Non-signatory Participation (ESA: Gateway MoU and Artemis Accords – FAQs)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "ESA participates operationally in Artemis (Gateway) but cannot sign the Accords; signature is left to its member states one by one, creating dual-track legitimation. No ESA statement \"welcoming the principles\" was…",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Non-signatory Participation",
    "document": "ESA: Gateway MoU and Artemis Accords – FAQs",
    "documentIds": [
     "ESA-STMT-2023"
    ],
    "section": "FAQ: \"What are the Artemis Accords?\"",
    "holder": "ESA member states, each deciding whether to sign",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "type": "procedural_deferral"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-012",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Phase 4 Exploration (SCIO briefing on \"China’s Space Program: A 2021 Perspective\" (lunar exploration Phase 4))",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Phased programme structure allows iterative expansion of scope without requiring partner re-consent at each stage. Architectural decisions cascade.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Phase 4 Exploration",
    "document": "SCIO briefing on \"China’s Space Program: A 2021 Perspective\" (lunar exploration Phase 4)",
    "documentIds": [
     "CN-LEP4-2024"
    ],
    "section": "SCIO briefing, 28 January 2022 (Wu Yanhua, CNSA)",
    "holder": "CNSA (state agency)",
    "coalition": "ilrs",
    "type": "procedural_deferral"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-013",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "As Appropriate (Artemis Accords)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "\"As appropriate\" delegates implementation entirely to the signatory. No external standard defines what is or is not appropriate, allowing each actor to calibrate compliance to their own interests.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "As Appropriate",
    "document": "Artemis Accords",
    "documentIds": [
     "AA-2020"
    ],
    "section": "Section 1 (Purpose and Scope), second paragraph",
    "holder": "Each Signatory (self-judging)",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "type": "open_ended_qualifier"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-015",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Authorisation by IN-SPACe (Indian Space Policy 2023)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Authorisation is defined only as permission granted by IN-SPACe; the criteria are left to IN-SPACe \"subject to relevant Government directives\" (Section 5). A policy document, not legislation.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Authorisation by IN-SPACe",
    "document": "Indian Space Policy 2023",
    "documentIds": [
     "IN-ISP-2023"
    ],
    "section": "Definitions, no. 1; Section 5",
    "holder": "IN-SPACe, subject to Government directives",
    "coalition": "national",
    "type": "procedural_deferral"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-016",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Interoperability Standards (LunaNet Interoperability Specification (Version 5))",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "The specification is written and approved jointly by NASA, ESA and JAXA, but the document is controlled by NASA’s SCaN board. Mutual agreement on paper coexists with a US-held control point for the baseline standards.",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Interoperability Standards",
    "document": "LunaNet Interoperability Specification (Version 5)",
    "documentIds": [
     "NASA-LUNANET"
    ],
    "section": "Section 1 (Introduction)",
    "holder": "NASA SCaN Control Board (document control); NASA, ESA and JAXA (authors)",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "type": "procedural_deferral"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:dp-017",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "discretion-point",
   "label": "Ownership vs. Appropriation (Luxembourg Space Resources Law + U.S. Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "The boundary between \"ownership of extracted resources\" (permitted) and \"appropriation of celestial bodies\" (prohibited by OST) is drawn unilaterally by national legislation without international adjudication. The US…",
   "fields": {
    "term": "Ownership vs. Appropriation",
    "document": "Luxembourg Space Resources Law + U.S. Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act",
    "documentIds": [
     "LUX-SRL-2017",
     "US-CSLCA-2015"
    ],
    "section": "51 U.S.C. 51303 / Luxembourg Art. 1",
    "holder": "National legislatures (Luxembourg, USA)",
    "coalition": "national",
    "type": "definitional_gap"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:country-usa",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "country-profile",
   "label": "United States lunar authority profile",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Defines safety zones, time standards, and interoperability requirements that all partners must adopt.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United States",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "documents": [
     "Artemis Accords",
     "OSTP Coordinated Lunar Time (LTC) Framework"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:country-china",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "country-profile",
   "label": "China lunar authority profile",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "CNSA controls station architecture, phase definitions, and partner onboarding criteria.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "China",
    "coalition": "ilrs",
    "documents": [
     "ILRS Guide for Partnership (V1.0, CNSA and Roscosmos)",
     "SCIO briefing on \"China’s Space Program: A 2021 Perspective\" (lunar exploration Phase 4)"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:country-russia",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "country-profile",
   "label": "Russia lunar authority profile",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Co-founding status grants architectural veto and privileged consultation not available to later joiners.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Russia",
    "coalition": "ilrs",
    "documents": [
     "China–Russia intergovernmental Memorandum of Understanding on the ILRS (9 March 2021)"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:country-japan",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "country-profile",
   "label": "Japan lunar authority profile",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "The Act does not define \"peaceful\"; the Government, in applying Articles 2 and 14, decides what it permits in practice.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Japan",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "documents": [
     "Japan Basic Space Law",
     "JAXA-NASA Artemis MoU (Gateway / HLS)"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:country-india",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "country-profile",
   "label": "India lunar authority profile",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "IN-SPACe holds exclusive authorization power over all commercial and international space activity by Indian entities.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "India",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "documents": [
     "Indian Space Policy 2023"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:country-luxembourg",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "country-profile",
   "label": "Luxembourg lunar authority profile",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Unilaterally declares space resources appropriable and licenses extraction (Art. 2) without multilateral consent.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "Luxembourg",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "documents": [
     "Luxembourg Space Resources Law"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:country-uae",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "country-profile",
   "label": "United Arab Emirates lunar authority profile",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "\"National interest\" override allows selective opacity despite formal transparency commitments.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "United Arab Emirates",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "documents": [
     "UAE Federal Law No. 12 of 2019 on the Regulation of the Space Sector"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:country-esa",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "country-profile",
   "label": "ESA / European Union lunar authority profile",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Defers authority to \"future multilateral norms\" while locking in operational participation now — the norms will have to accommodate the facts.",
   "fields": {
    "country": "ESA / European Union",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "documents": [
     "ESA: Gateway MoU and Artemis Accords – FAQs"
    ]
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:igl-001",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "infrastructure-link",
   "label": "Navigation: NASA / OSTP",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Defining Coordinated Lunar Time (LTC) creates a reference frame all cislunar actors must synchronize to. Operational necessity becomes normative infrastructure.",
   "fields": {
    "infrastructure": "nav",
    "controller": "NASA / OSTP",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "example": "OSTP Lunar Time Standard directive (2024)"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:igl-002",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "infrastructure-link",
   "label": "Communications: NASA (LunaNet)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Relay network architecture determines who can communicate, when, and through what protocols. Network access = operational permission.",
   "fields": {
    "infrastructure": "comms",
    "controller": "NASA (LunaNet)",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "example": "LunaNet interoperability standards"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:igl-003",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "infrastructure-link",
   "label": "Power Systems: CNSA (ILRS Phase 4)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Nuclear fission power plant at lunar south pole creates dependency. Power sharing agreements become governance instruments.",
   "fields": {
    "infrastructure": "power",
    "controller": "CNSA (ILRS Phase 4)",
    "coalition": "ilrs",
    "example": "ILRS nuclear power plant for south pole base"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:igl-004",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "infrastructure-link",
   "label": "In-Situ Resource Utilization: Multiple (contested)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "First extraction creates operational precedent. \"Safety zones\" around extraction sites convert resource use into spatial authority.",
   "fields": {
    "infrastructure": "ISRU",
    "controller": "Multiple (contested)",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "example": "Artemis Accords Section 11 + Luxembourg Space Resources Law"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:igl-005",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "infrastructure-link",
   "label": "Space Situational Awareness: US Space Command / 18th SDS",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Comprehensive tracking capability creates information asymmetry. The actor who \"sees\" the space environment defines what constitutes risk.",
   "fields": {
    "infrastructure": "SSA",
    "controller": "US Space Command / 18th SDS",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "example": "Space fence radar + cislunar domain awareness expansion"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:igl-006",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "infrastructure-link",
   "label": "Habitats: CNSA / Roscosmos (ILRS)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Permanent presence converts occupancy into operational authority. Habitat location choices pre-empt future resource access by establishing \"prior use.\"",
   "fields": {
    "infrastructure": "habitats",
    "controller": "CNSA / Roscosmos (ILRS)",
    "coalition": "ilrs",
    "example": "ILRS south pole base site selection"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "lunar:igl-007",
   "kind": "record",
   "domain": "lunar",
   "type": "infrastructure-link",
   "label": "Logistics: NASA (Gateway + HLS)",
   "date": null,
   "year": null,
   "url": "https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app/",
   "urlPrecision": "root",
   "summary": "Controlling the logistics chain (orbital station, lander, surface transport) determines who can reach the lunar surface and when.",
   "fields": {
    "infrastructure": "logistics",
    "controller": "NASA (Gateway + HLS)",
    "coalition": "artemis",
    "example": "Lunar Gateway as staging point + HLS contract structure"
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "state:russia",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Russia",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:ukraine",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Ukraine",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:united-states",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "United States",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:united-kingdom",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "United Kingdom",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:iran",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Iran",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:north-korea",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "North Korea",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:germany",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Germany",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:france",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "France",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:italy",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Italy",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:china",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "China",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:saudi-arabia",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Saudi Arabia",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:bangladesh",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Bangladesh",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:australia",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Australia",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:taiwan",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Taiwan",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:india",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "India",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:pakistan",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Pakistan",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:israel",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Israel",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:egypt",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Egypt",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:belgium",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Belgium",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:canada",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Canada",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:south-korea",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "South Korea",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:japan",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Japan",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:netherlands",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Netherlands",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:sweden",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Sweden",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:switzerland",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Switzerland",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:brazil",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Brazil",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:finland",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Finland",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:czech-republic",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Czech Republic",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:hungary",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Hungary",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:spain",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Spain",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "United Arab Emirates",
   "domains": [
    "lunar",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:argentina",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Argentina",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:south-africa",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "South Africa",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:mexico",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Mexico",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:romania",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Romania",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:slovenia",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Slovenia",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:armenia",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Armenia",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:belarus",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Belarus",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:turkey",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Turkey",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:luxembourg",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Luxembourg",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "state:eu-esa",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "state",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "European Union / ESA",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "sector:energy-power",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "sector",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Energy and power",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "sector:communications",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "sector",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Communications",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "sector",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Navigation and timing",
   "domains": [
    "lunar",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Tallinn Manual 2.0",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:un-charter",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "UN Charter",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:ihl",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Geneva Conventions / IHL",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015)",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:ilc-articles-on-state-responsibility-art-8",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:wassenaar-arrangement",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Wassenaar Arrangement",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:un-oewg-2021-recommendations",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "UN OEWG 2021 recommendations",
   "domains": [
    "cyber"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Outer Space Treaty (1967)",
   "domains": [
    "lunar",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Artemis Accords",
   "domains": [
    "lunar",
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:ilrs-mou-2021",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "China–Russia intergovernmental Memorandum of Understanding on the ILRS (9 March 2021)",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:ilrs-guide-2023",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "ILRS Guide for Partnership (V1.0, CNSA and Roscosmos)",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:uae-law-2019",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "UAE Federal Law No. 12 of 2019 on the Regulation of the Space Sector",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:jp-bsl-2008",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Japan Basic Space Law",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:lux-srl-2017",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Luxembourg Space Resources Law",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:in-sab-2023",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Draft Space Activities Bill, 2017 (India)",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:us-ostp-ltc-2024",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "OSTP Coordinated Lunar Time (LTC) Framework",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:esa-stmt-2023",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "ESA: Gateway MoU and Artemis Accords – FAQs",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:cn-lep4-2024",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "SCIO briefing on \"China’s Space Program: A 2021 Perspective\" (lunar exploration Phase 4)",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:in-isp-2023",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Indian Space Policy 2023",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:nasa-lunanet",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "LunaNet Interoperability Specification (Version 5)",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:us-cslca-2015",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "U.S. Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:jp-nasa-2022",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "JAXA-NASA Artemis MoU (Gateway / HLS)",
   "domains": [
    "lunar"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:npt",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "NPT",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:tlatelolco",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Treaty of Tlatelolco",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "IAEA Additional Protocol",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:tpnw",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "TPNW",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:euratom",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "EURATOM",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:pelindaba",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Treaty of Pelindaba",
   "domains": [
    "nuclear"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:liability-convention",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Liability Convention (1972)",
   "domains": [
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:registration-convention",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "Registration Convention (1975)",
   "domains": [
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019)",
   "domains": [
    "orbital"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "instrument:itu-framework",
   "kind": "entity",
   "type": "instrument",
   "domain": "shared",
   "label": "ITU Coordination",
   "domains": [
    "orbital"
   ]
  }
 ],
 "edges": [
  {
   "id": "e1",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:notpetya",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e2",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:notpetya",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"UA\" (Ukraine).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e3",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:solarwinds",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e4",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:solarwinds",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e5",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:solarwinds",
   "target": "state:united-kingdom",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"GB\" (United Kingdom).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e6",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:stuxnet",
   "target": "state:iran",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"IR\" (Iran).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e7",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:sony-pictures",
   "target": "state:north-korea",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"North Korea\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"North Korea\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e8",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:sony-pictures",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e9",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e10",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"UA\" (Ukraine).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e11",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e12",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"UA\" (Ukraine).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e13",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:wannacry",
   "target": "state:north-korea",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"North Korea\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"North Korea\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e14",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e15",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:oldsmar-water",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e16",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e17",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"UA\" (Ukraine).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e18",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "state:germany",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"DE\" (Germany).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e19",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "state:france",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"FR\" (France).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e20",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "state:italy",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"IT\" (Italy).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e21",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:exchange-hafnium",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e22",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:exchange-hafnium",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e23",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:albania-iran",
   "target": "state:iran",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Iran\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Iran\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e24",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:shamoon-aramco",
   "target": "state:saudi-arabia",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"SA\" (Saudi Arabia).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e25",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:bangladesh-bank-swift",
   "target": "state:north-korea",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"North Korea\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"North Korea\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e26",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:bangladesh-bank-swift",
   "target": "state:bangladesh",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"BD\" (Bangladesh).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e27",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:australia-parliament",
   "target": "state:australia",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"AU\" (Australia).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e28",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:iran-nuclear-cyber",
   "target": "state:iran",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"IR\" (Iran).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e29",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:taiwan-telecom",
   "target": "state:taiwan",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"TW\" (Taiwan).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e30",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:industroyer2",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e31",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:industroyer2",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"UA\" (Ukraine).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e32",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:scattered-spider-mgm",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e33",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:storm-0558",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e34",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:storm-0558",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e35",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:change-healthcare",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e36",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:volt-typhoon",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e37",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:volt-typhoon",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e38",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:midnight-blizzard",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e39",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:midnight-blizzard",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e40",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:kyivstar",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e41",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:kyivstar",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"UA\" (Ukraine).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e42",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:india-pakistan-cyber",
   "target": "state:india",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"IN\" (India).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e43",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:india-pakistan-cyber",
   "target": "state:pakistan",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"PK\" (Pakistan).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e44",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt-c23-gaza-cybergang",
   "target": "state:israel",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"IL\" (Israel).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e45",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt-c23-gaza-cybergang",
   "target": "state:egypt",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"EG\" (Egypt).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e46",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist",
   "target": "state:united-kingdom",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"United Kingdom\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"United Kingdom\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e47",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist",
   "target": "state:belgium",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"BE\" (Belgium).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e48",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:opm-breach",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e49",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:opm-breach",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e50",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e51",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e52",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "state:canada",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"CA\" (Canada).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e53",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "state:united-kingdom",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"GB\" (United Kingdom).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e54",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "state:south-korea",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"KR\" (South Korea).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e55",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "state:japan",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"JP\" (Japan).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e56",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "state:taiwan",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"TW\" (Taiwan).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e57",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:salt-typhoon",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e58",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:salt-typhoon",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e59",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:flame-flamer",
   "target": "state:iran",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"IR\" (Iran).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e60",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:flame-flamer",
   "target": "state:israel",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"IL\" (Israel).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e61",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:flame-flamer",
   "target": "state:saudi-arabia",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"SA\" (Saudi Arabia).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e62",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:flame-flamer",
   "target": "state:egypt",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"EG\" (Egypt).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e63",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field attribution.country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "cyber attribution.country \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e64",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"US\" (United States).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e65",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:united-kingdom",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"GB\" (United Kingdom).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e66",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:japan",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"JP\" (Japan).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e67",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:australia",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"AU\" (Australia).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e68",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:canada",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"CA\" (Canada).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e69",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:france",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"FR\" (France).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e70",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:germany",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"DE\" (Germany).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e71",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:netherlands",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"NL\" (Netherlands).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e72",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:sweden",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"SE\" (Sweden).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e73",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:switzerland",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"CH\" (Switzerland).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e74",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:brazil",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"BR\" (Brazil).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e75",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:india",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"IN\" (India).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e76",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "state:south-korea",
   "basis": "target_state",
   "basisText": "Cyber case field infrastructure.targetCountries lists \"KR\" (South Korea).",
   "role": "target"
  },
  {
   "id": "e77",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:2",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e78",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:3",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"United States\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e79",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:6",
   "target": "state:north-korea",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"North Korea\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"North Korea\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e80",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:7",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e81",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:8",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e82",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:9",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e83",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:10",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia (attributed: FSB Turla APT)\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia (attributed: FSB Turla APT)\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e84",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:11",
   "target": "state:north-korea",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"North Korea\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"North Korea\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e85",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:12",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e86",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:13",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e87",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:14",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e88",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:15",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e89",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:16",
   "target": "state:india",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"India\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"India\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e90",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:17",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e91",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:19",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e92",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:20",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e93",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:21",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e94",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:22",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e95",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:23",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e96",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:24",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e97",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:26",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"China\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "high",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e98",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:27",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "attributed_state",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident field actor reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "attributed",
   "confidence": "confirmed",
   "raw": "orbital actor \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e99",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-palo-verde",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e100",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-vogtle",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e101",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-south-texas",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e102",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-diablo-canyon",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e103",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-peach-bottom",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e104",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-braidwood",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e105",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-comanche-peak",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e106",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-watts-bar",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e107",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-browns-ferry",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e108",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-calvert-cliffs",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e109",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-seabrook",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e110",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-millstone",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e111",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-north-anna",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e112",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-oconee",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e113",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-grand-gulf",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e114",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-turkey-point",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e115",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-columbia",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e116",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-indian-point",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e117",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-three-mile-island",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e118",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-san-onofre",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United States\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e119",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-gravelines",
   "target": "state:france",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"France\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e120",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-cattenom",
   "target": "state:france",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"France\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e121",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-paluel",
   "target": "state:france",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"France\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e122",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-flamanville",
   "target": "state:france",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"France\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e123",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-chinon",
   "target": "state:france",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"France\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e124",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-blayais",
   "target": "state:france",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"France\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e125",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-qinshan",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e126",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-daya-bay",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e127",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-tianwan",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e128",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-hongyanhe",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e129",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-yangjiang",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e130",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-taishan",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"China\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e131",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-balakovo",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e132",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-leningrad",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e133",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-kalinin",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e134",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-smolensk",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e135",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-beloyarsk",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Russia\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e136",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:kr-kori",
   "target": "state:south-korea",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"South Korea\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e137",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:kr-hanul",
   "target": "state:south-korea",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"South Korea\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e138",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:kr-hanbit",
   "target": "state:south-korea",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"South Korea\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e139",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ca-bruce",
   "target": "state:canada",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Canada\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e140",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ca-darlington",
   "target": "state:canada",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Canada\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e141",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ca-pickering",
   "target": "state:canada",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Canada\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e142",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:gb-sizewell-b",
   "target": "state:united-kingdom",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United Kingdom\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e143",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:gb-heysham",
   "target": "state:united-kingdom",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United Kingdom\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e144",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:gb-torness",
   "target": "state:united-kingdom",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United Kingdom\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e145",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:gb-hinkley-c",
   "target": "state:united-kingdom",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United Kingdom\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e146",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:jp-sendai",
   "target": "state:japan",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Japan\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e147",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:jp-genkai",
   "target": "state:japan",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Japan\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e148",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:jp-takahama",
   "target": "state:japan",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Japan\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e149",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:jp-fukushima-daini",
   "target": "state:japan",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Japan\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e150",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:in-kudankulam",
   "target": "state:india",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"India\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e151",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:in-tarapur",
   "target": "state:india",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"India\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e152",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:in-rajasthan",
   "target": "state:india",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"India\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e153",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ua-zaporizhzhia",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Ukraine\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e154",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ua-rivne",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Ukraine\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e155",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ua-south-ukraine",
   "target": "state:ukraine",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Ukraine\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e156",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fi-olkiluoto",
   "target": "state:finland",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Finland\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e157",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fi-loviisa",
   "target": "state:finland",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Finland\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e158",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:se-forsmark",
   "target": "state:sweden",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Sweden\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e159",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:se-ringhals",
   "target": "state:sweden",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Sweden\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e160",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:be-doel",
   "target": "state:belgium",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Belgium\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e161",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:be-tihange",
   "target": "state:belgium",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Belgium\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e162",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cz-dukovany",
   "target": "state:czech-republic",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Czech Republic\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e163",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cz-temelin",
   "target": "state:czech-republic",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Czech Republic\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e164",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:hu-paks",
   "target": "state:hungary",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Hungary\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e165",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:es-almaraz",
   "target": "state:spain",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Spain\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e166",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:es-cofrentes",
   "target": "state:spain",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Spain\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e167",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ch-leibstadt",
   "target": "state:switzerland",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Switzerland\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e168",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ch-beznau",
   "target": "state:switzerland",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Switzerland\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e169",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:de-isar",
   "target": "state:germany",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Germany\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e170",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:nl-borssele",
   "target": "state:netherlands",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Netherlands\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e171",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ae-barakah",
   "target": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"United Arab Emirates\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e172",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ar-atucha",
   "target": "state:argentina",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Argentina\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e173",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:br-angra",
   "target": "state:brazil",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Brazil\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e174",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:za-koeberg",
   "target": "state:south-africa",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"South Africa\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e175",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:pk-kanupp",
   "target": "state:pakistan",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Pakistan\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e176",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ir-bushehr",
   "target": "state:iran",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Iran\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e177",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:mx-laguna-verde",
   "target": "state:mexico",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Mexico\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e178",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ro-cernavoda",
   "target": "state:romania",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Romania\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e179",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:si-krsko",
   "target": "state:slovenia",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Slovenia\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e180",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:am-metsamor",
   "target": "state:armenia",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Armenia\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e181",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:by-ostrovets",
   "target": "state:belarus",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Belarus\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e182",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:bd-rooppur",
   "target": "state:bangladesh",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Bangladesh\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e183",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:tr-akkuyu",
   "target": "state:turkey",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Turkey\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e184",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:eg-el-dabaa",
   "target": "state:egypt",
   "basis": "host_state",
   "basisText": "Nuclear plant field country reads \"Egypt\".",
   "role": "host"
  },
  {
   "id": "e185",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-usa",
   "target": "state:united-states",
   "basis": "profiled_state",
   "basisText": "State profiled in lunar data: the lunar atlas has a country authority profile for \"United States\". A profile is not an actor in an event.",
   "role": "profiled",
   "raw": "lunar country profile \"United States\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e186",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-china",
   "target": "state:china",
   "basis": "profiled_state",
   "basisText": "State profiled in lunar data: the lunar atlas has a country authority profile for \"China\". A profile is not an actor in an event.",
   "role": "profiled",
   "raw": "lunar country profile \"China\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e187",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-russia",
   "target": "state:russia",
   "basis": "profiled_state",
   "basisText": "State profiled in lunar data: the lunar atlas has a country authority profile for \"Russia\". A profile is not an actor in an event.",
   "role": "profiled",
   "raw": "lunar country profile \"Russia\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e188",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-japan",
   "target": "state:japan",
   "basis": "profiled_state",
   "basisText": "State profiled in lunar data: the lunar atlas has a country authority profile for \"Japan\". A profile is not an actor in an event.",
   "role": "profiled",
   "raw": "lunar country profile \"Japan\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e189",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-india",
   "target": "state:india",
   "basis": "profiled_state",
   "basisText": "State profiled in lunar data: the lunar atlas has a country authority profile for \"India\". A profile is not an actor in an event.",
   "role": "profiled",
   "raw": "lunar country profile \"India\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e190",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-luxembourg",
   "target": "state:luxembourg",
   "basis": "profiled_state",
   "basisText": "State profiled in lunar data: the lunar atlas has a country authority profile for \"Luxembourg\". A profile is not an actor in an event.",
   "role": "profiled",
   "raw": "lunar country profile \"Luxembourg\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e191",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-uae",
   "target": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "basis": "profiled_state",
   "basisText": "State profiled in lunar data: the lunar atlas has a country authority profile for \"United Arab Emirates\". A profile is not an actor in an event.",
   "role": "profiled",
   "raw": "lunar country profile \"United Arab Emirates\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e192",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-esa",
   "target": "state:eu-esa",
   "basis": "profiled_state",
   "basisText": "State profiled in lunar data: the lunar atlas has a country authority profile for \"ESA / European Union\". A profile is not an actor in an event.",
   "role": "profiled",
   "raw": "lunar country profile \"ESA / European Union\""
  },
  {
   "id": "e193",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:stuxnet",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e194",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e195",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e196",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:wannacry",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e197",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e198",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e199",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e200",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:shamoon-aramco",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e201",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:iran-nuclear-cyber",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e202",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:taiwan-telecom",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e203",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:industroyer2",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e204",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:volt-typhoon",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e205",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:volt-typhoon",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e206",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:kyivstar",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e207",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e208",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e209",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e210",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:salt-typhoon",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e211",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:flame-flamer",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"energy\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e212",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Cyber case targetSectors includes \"telecommunications\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e213",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:5",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"spoofing\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e214",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:6",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident target or subtype mentions a communications service (\"South Korean aviation, shipping, military communications\")."
  },
  {
   "id": "e215",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:6",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"jamming\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e216",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:10",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident target or subtype mentions a communications service (\"Commercial satellite internet links (multiple countries)\")."
  },
  {
   "id": "e217",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:11",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"jamming\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e218",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:13",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"spoofing\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e219",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:15",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"jamming\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e220",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:18",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"spoofing\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e221",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:21",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident target or subtype mentions a communications service (\"Viasat KA-SAT network (Ukraine + ~40,000 modems across Europe)\")."
  },
  {
   "id": "e222",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:22",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident target or subtype mentions a communications service (\"SpaceX Starlink terminals (Ukrainian military and civilian users)\")."
  },
  {
   "id": "e223",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:23",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"jamming\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e224",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:25",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"spoofing\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e225",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "orbital:28",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Orbital incident type is \"spoofing\" and the record concerns satellite navigation signals."
  },
  {
   "id": "e226",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-palo-verde",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e227",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-vogtle",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e228",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-south-texas",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e229",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-diablo-canyon",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e230",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-peach-bottom",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e231",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-braidwood",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e232",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-comanche-peak",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e233",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-watts-bar",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e234",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-browns-ferry",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e235",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-calvert-cliffs",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e236",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-seabrook",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e237",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-millstone",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e238",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-north-anna",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e239",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-oconee",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e240",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-grand-gulf",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e241",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-turkey-point",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e242",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-columbia",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e243",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-indian-point",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e244",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-three-mile-island",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e245",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:us-san-onofre",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e246",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-gravelines",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e247",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-cattenom",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e248",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-paluel",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e249",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-flamanville",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e250",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-chinon",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e251",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fr-blayais",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e252",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-qinshan",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e253",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-daya-bay",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e254",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-tianwan",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e255",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-hongyanhe",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e256",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-yangjiang",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e257",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cn-taishan",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e258",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-balakovo",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e259",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-leningrad",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e260",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-kalinin",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e261",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-smolensk",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e262",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ru-beloyarsk",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e263",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:kr-kori",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e264",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:kr-hanul",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e265",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:kr-hanbit",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e266",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ca-bruce",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e267",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ca-darlington",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e268",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ca-pickering",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e269",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:gb-sizewell-b",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e270",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:gb-heysham",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e271",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:gb-torness",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e272",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:gb-hinkley-c",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e273",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:jp-sendai",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e274",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:jp-genkai",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e275",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:jp-takahama",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e276",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:jp-fukushima-daini",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e277",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:in-kudankulam",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e278",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:in-tarapur",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e279",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:in-rajasthan",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e280",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ua-zaporizhzhia",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e281",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ua-rivne",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e282",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ua-south-ukraine",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e283",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fi-olkiluoto",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e284",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:fi-loviisa",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e285",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:se-forsmark",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e286",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:se-ringhals",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e287",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:be-doel",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e288",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:be-tihange",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e289",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cz-dukovany",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e290",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:cz-temelin",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e291",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:hu-paks",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e292",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:es-almaraz",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e293",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:es-cofrentes",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e294",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ch-leibstadt",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e295",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ch-beznau",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e296",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:de-isar",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e297",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:nl-borssele",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e298",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ae-barakah",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e299",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ar-atucha",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e300",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:br-angra",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e301",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:za-koeberg",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e302",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:pk-kanupp",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e303",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ir-bushehr",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e304",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:mx-laguna-verde",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e305",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:ro-cernavoda",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e306",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:si-krsko",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e307",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:am-metsamor",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e308",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:by-ostrovets",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e309",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:bd-rooppur",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e310",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:tr-akkuyu",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e311",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "nuclear:eg-el-dabaa",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas record is a commercial nuclear power plant."
  },
  {
   "id": "e312",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:igl-001",
   "target": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Lunar infrastructure link type is \"nav\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e313",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:igl-002",
   "target": "sector:communications",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Lunar infrastructure link type is \"comms\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e314",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:igl-003",
   "target": "sector:energy-power",
   "basis": "infrastructure_category",
   "basisText": "Lunar infrastructure link type is \"power\"."
  },
  {
   "id": "e315",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r14"
  },
  {
   "id": "e316",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:costa-rica-conti",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r14"
  },
  {
   "id": "e317",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:wannacry",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r14"
  },
  {
   "id": "e318",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r14"
  },
  {
   "id": "e319",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:salt-typhoon",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r14"
  },
  {
   "id": "e320",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rules 14, 15 and 17, State Responsibility and Attribution",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r14"
  },
  {
   "id": "e321",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:volt-typhoon",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rules 6 and 7, Due Diligence.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rules 6 and 7, Due Diligence",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r6"
  },
  {
   "id": "e322",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 93, Distinction.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rule 93, Distinction",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r93"
  },
  {
   "id": "e323",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:kyivstar",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 93, Distinction.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rule 93, Distinction",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r93"
  },
  {
   "id": "e324",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 93, Distinction.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rule 93, Distinction",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r93"
  },
  {
   "id": "e325",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:notpetya",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 113, Proportionality.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rule 113, Proportionality",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r113"
  },
  {
   "id": "e326",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:stuxnet",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 113, Proportionality.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rule 113, Proportionality",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r113"
  },
  {
   "id": "e327",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:iran-nuclear-cyber",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 20, Countermeasures.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rule 20, Countermeasures",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r20"
  },
  {
   "id": "e328",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:albania-iran",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 20, Countermeasures.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rule 20, Countermeasures",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r20"
  },
  {
   "id": "e329",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:australia-parliament",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 66, Intervention.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Rule 66, Intervention",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:tallinn-r66"
  },
  {
   "id": "e330",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:stuxnet",
   "target": "instrument:un-charter",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN Charter, Article 2(4), Prohibition on the Use of Force.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article 2(4), Prohibition on the Use of Force",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:un-2-4"
  },
  {
   "id": "e331",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:notpetya",
   "target": "instrument:un-charter",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN Charter, Article 2(4), Prohibition on the Use of Force.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article 2(4), Prohibition on the Use of Force",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:un-2-4"
  },
  {
   "id": "e332",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "instrument:un-charter",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN Charter, Article 2(4), Prohibition on the Use of Force.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article 2(4), Prohibition on the Use of Force",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:un-2-4"
  },
  {
   "id": "e333",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "target": "instrument:un-charter",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN Charter, Article 51, Self-Defence.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article 51, Self-Defence",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:un-51"
  },
  {
   "id": "e334",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:shamoon-aramco",
   "target": "instrument:un-charter",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN Charter, Article 51, Self-Defence.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article 51, Self-Defence",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:un-51"
  },
  {
   "id": "e335",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:kyivstar",
   "target": "instrument:ihl",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Geneva Conventions / IHL, Principle of Distinction.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Principle of Distinction",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:ihl-distinction"
  },
  {
   "id": "e336",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "instrument:ihl",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Geneva Conventions / IHL, Principle of Distinction.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Principle of Distinction",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:ihl-distinction"
  },
  {
   "id": "e337",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:industroyer2",
   "target": "instrument:ihl",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Geneva Conventions / IHL, Principle of Distinction.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Principle of Distinction",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:ihl-distinction"
  },
  {
   "id": "e338",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:notpetya",
   "target": "instrument:ihl",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Geneva Conventions / IHL, Principle of Proportionality.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Principle of Proportionality",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:ihl-proportionality"
  },
  {
   "id": "e339",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:wannacry",
   "target": "instrument:ihl",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Geneva Conventions / IHL, Principle of Proportionality.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Principle of Proportionality",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:ihl-proportionality"
  },
  {
   "id": "e340",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:stuxnet",
   "target": "instrument:ihl",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under Geneva Conventions / IHL, Precaution in Attack.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Precaution in Attack",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:ihl-precaution"
  },
  {
   "id": "e341",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:exchange-hafnium",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(a), Cooperation on Security.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(a), Cooperation on Security",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13a"
  },
  {
   "id": "e342",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:volt-typhoon",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(a), Cooperation on Security.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(a), Cooperation on Security",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13a"
  },
  {
   "id": "e343",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13f"
  },
  {
   "id": "e344",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:notpetya",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13f"
  },
  {
   "id": "e345",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13f"
  },
  {
   "id": "e346",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:kyivstar",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13f"
  },
  {
   "id": "e347",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:salt-typhoon",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13f"
  },
  {
   "id": "e348",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(f), Critical Infrastructure Protection",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13f"
  },
  {
   "id": "e349",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:wannacry",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(j), Vulnerability Disclosure.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(j), Vulnerability Disclosure",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13j"
  },
  {
   "id": "e350",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:storm-0558",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber legal framework table lists this case under UN GGE Voluntary Norms (2015), Norm 13(j), Vulnerability Disclosure.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Norm 13(j), Vulnerability Disclosure",
   "via": "legalFrameworks:gge-13j"
  },
  {
   "id": "e351",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Prohibition on Targeting Civilian Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 93 – Distinction.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 93 – Distinction",
   "via": "norms:civilian-infrastructure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e352",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:industroyer2",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Prohibition on Targeting Civilian Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 93 – Distinction.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 93 – Distinction",
   "via": "norms:civilian-infrastructure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e353",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Prohibition on Targeting Civilian Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(f).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(f)",
   "via": "norms:civilian-infrastructure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e354",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Prohibition on Targeting Civilian Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(f).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(f)",
   "via": "norms:civilian-infrastructure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e355",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:industroyer2",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Prohibition on Targeting Civilian Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(f).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(f)",
   "via": "norms:civilian-infrastructure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e356",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
   "target": "instrument:ilc-articles-on-state-responsibility-art-8",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"State Responsibility for Proxy and Contractor Operations\", anchored in ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8",
   "via": "norms:state-proxy-responsibility"
  },
  {
   "id": "e357",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:costa-rica-conti",
   "target": "instrument:ilc-articles-on-state-responsibility-art-8",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"State Responsibility for Proxy and Contractor Operations\", anchored in ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8",
   "via": "norms:state-proxy-responsibility"
  },
  {
   "id": "e358",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:scattered-spider-mgm",
   "target": "instrument:ilc-articles-on-state-responsibility-art-8",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"State Responsibility for Proxy and Contractor Operations\", anchored in ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8",
   "via": "norms:state-proxy-responsibility"
  },
  {
   "id": "e359",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:wannacry",
   "target": "instrument:ilc-articles-on-state-responsibility-art-8",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"State Responsibility for Proxy and Contractor Operations\", anchored in ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8",
   "via": "norms:state-proxy-responsibility"
  },
  {
   "id": "e360",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:salt-typhoon",
   "target": "instrument:ilc-articles-on-state-responsibility-art-8",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"State Responsibility for Proxy and Contractor Operations\", anchored in ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8",
   "via": "norms:state-proxy-responsibility"
  },
  {
   "id": "e361",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10",
   "target": "instrument:ilc-articles-on-state-responsibility-art-8",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"State Responsibility for Proxy and Contractor Operations\", anchored in ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "ILC Articles on State Responsibility Art. 8",
   "via": "norms:state-proxy-responsibility"
  },
  {
   "id": "e362",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:scattered-spider-mgm",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"State Responsibility for Proxy and Contractor Operations\", anchored in Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 14 – Internationally wrongful cyber acts; Rule 17 – Attribution of cyber operations by non-State actors.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 14 – Internationally wrongful cyber acts; Rule 17 – Attribution of cyber operations by non-State actors",
   "via": "norms:state-proxy-responsibility"
  },
  {
   "id": "e363",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:sony-pictures",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Proportionality in Cyber Operations\", anchored in Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 113 – Proportionality; Rule 23 – Proportionality of countermeasures.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 113 – Proportionality; Rule 23 – Proportionality of countermeasures",
   "via": "norms:proportionality"
  },
  {
   "id": "e364",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:shamoon-aramco",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Proportionality in Cyber Operations\", anchored in Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 113 – Proportionality; Rule 23 – Proportionality of countermeasures.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 113 – Proportionality; Rule 23 – Proportionality of countermeasures",
   "via": "norms:proportionality"
  },
  {
   "id": "e365",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:sony-pictures",
   "target": "instrument:un-charter",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Proportionality in Cyber Operations\", anchored in UN Charter Art. 51.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN Charter Art. 51",
   "via": "norms:proportionality"
  },
  {
   "id": "e366",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:sony-pictures",
   "target": "instrument:ihl",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Proportionality in Cyber Operations\", anchored in IHL Additional Protocol I Art. 51(5)(b).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "IHL Additional Protocol I Art. 51(5)(b)",
   "via": "norms:proportionality"
  },
  {
   "id": "e367",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:shamoon-aramco",
   "target": "instrument:ihl",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Proportionality in Cyber Operations\", anchored in IHL Additional Protocol I Art. 51(5)(b).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "IHL Additional Protocol I Art. 51(5)(b)",
   "via": "norms:proportionality"
  },
  {
   "id": "e368",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:solarwinds",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Duty to Disclose Vulnerabilities (Responsible Disclosure)\", anchored in UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(j).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(j)",
   "via": "norms:vulnerability-disclosure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e369",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:wannacry",
   "target": "instrument:wassenaar-arrangement",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Duty to Disclose Vulnerabilities (Responsible Disclosure)\", anchored in Wassenaar Arrangement.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Wassenaar Arrangement",
   "via": "norms:vulnerability-disclosure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e370",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:exchange-hafnium",
   "target": "instrument:wassenaar-arrangement",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Duty to Disclose Vulnerabilities (Responsible Disclosure)\", anchored in Wassenaar Arrangement.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Wassenaar Arrangement",
   "via": "norms:vulnerability-disclosure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e371",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:solarwinds",
   "target": "instrument:wassenaar-arrangement",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Duty to Disclose Vulnerabilities (Responsible Disclosure)\", anchored in Wassenaar Arrangement.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Wassenaar Arrangement",
   "via": "norms:vulnerability-disclosure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e372",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:storm-0558",
   "target": "instrument:wassenaar-arrangement",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Duty to Disclose Vulnerabilities (Responsible Disclosure)\", anchored in Wassenaar Arrangement.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Wassenaar Arrangement",
   "via": "norms:vulnerability-disclosure"
  },
  {
   "id": "e373",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:australia-parliament",
   "target": "instrument:un-gge-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"Non-Interference in Electoral Infrastructure\", anchored in UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(b).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN GGE 2015 Norm 13(b)",
   "via": "norms:electoral-noninterference"
  },
  {
   "id": "e374",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:volt-typhoon",
   "target": "instrument:un-oewg-2021-recommendations",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"No-First-Use Norms in Peacetime Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in UN OEWG 2021 recommendations.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN OEWG 2021 recommendations",
   "via": "norms:no-first-use-ci"
  },
  {
   "id": "e375",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:taiwan-telecom",
   "target": "instrument:un-oewg-2021-recommendations",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"No-First-Use Norms in Peacetime Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in UN OEWG 2021 recommendations.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN OEWG 2021 recommendations",
   "via": "norms:no-first-use-ci"
  },
  {
   "id": "e376",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "target": "instrument:un-oewg-2021-recommendations",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"No-First-Use Norms in Peacetime Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in UN OEWG 2021 recommendations.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UN OEWG 2021 recommendations",
   "via": "norms:no-first-use-ci"
  },
  {
   "id": "e377",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "cyber:taiwan-telecom",
   "target": "instrument:tallinn-manual-2",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Cyber norms table lists this case under the norm \"No-First-Use Norms in Peacetime Critical Infrastructure\", anchored in Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 6 – Due diligence (general principle).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 6 – Due diligence (general principle)",
   "via": "norms:no-first-use-ci"
  },
  {
   "id": "e378",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-001",
   "target": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Outer Space Treaty (OST-1967), Article IX.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article IX: \"Due Regard\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:OST-1967"
  },
  {
   "id": "e379",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-002",
   "target": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Artemis Accords (AA-2020), Section 11, para. 4.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Section 11, para. 4: \"Harmful Interference\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:AA-2020"
  },
  {
   "id": "e380",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-003",
   "target": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Artemis Accords (AA-2020), Section 11, para. 7.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Section 11, para. 7: \"Safety Zone\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:AA-2020"
  },
  {
   "id": "e381",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-004",
   "target": "instrument:ilrs-mou-2021",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in China–Russia intergovernmental Memorandum of Understanding on the ILRS (9 March 2021) (ILRS-MOU-2021), MoU text not public; CNSA summary of 9 March 2021.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "MoU text not public; CNSA summary of 9 March 2021: \"Co-consultation\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:ILRS-MOU-2021"
  },
  {
   "id": "e382",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-005",
   "target": "instrument:ilrs-guide-2023",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in ILRS Guide for Partnership (V1.0, CNSA and Roscosmos) (ILRS-GUIDE-2023), Preface, p. 2.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Preface, p. 2: \"All Interested International Partners\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:ILRS-GUIDE-2023"
  },
  {
   "id": "e383",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-006",
   "target": "instrument:uae-law-2019",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in UAE Federal Law No. 12 of 2019 on the Regulation of the Space Sector (UAE-LAW-2019), Article 7 (as cited; not checked).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article 7 (as cited; not checked): \"National Interest\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:UAE-LAW-2019"
  },
  {
   "id": "e384",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-007",
   "target": "instrument:jp-bsl-2008",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Japan Basic Space Law (JP-BSL-2008), Article 2; see also Articles 3 and 14.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article 2; see also Articles 3 and 14: \"Peaceful Use (pacifist principles / national security)\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:JP-BSL-2008"
  },
  {
   "id": "e385",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-008",
   "target": "instrument:lux-srl-2017",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Luxembourg Space Resources Law (LUX-SRL-2017), Article 1.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Article 1: \"Space Resources Capable of Appropriation\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:LUX-SRL-2017"
  },
  {
   "id": "e386",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-009",
   "target": "instrument:in-sab-2023",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Draft Space Activities Bill, 2017 (India) (IN-SAB-2023), Chapter III, section 6(1).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Chapter III, section 6(1): \"Licence Requirement (draft)\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:IN-SAB-2023"
  },
  {
   "id": "e387",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-010",
   "target": "instrument:us-ostp-ltc-2024",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in OSTP Coordinated Lunar Time (LTC) Framework (US-OSTP-LTC-2024), OSTP memorandum, Section 2(b).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "OSTP memorandum, Section 2(b): \"Lunar Time Standard\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:US-OSTP-LTC-2024"
  },
  {
   "id": "e388",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-011",
   "target": "instrument:esa-stmt-2023",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in ESA: Gateway MoU and Artemis Accords – FAQs (ESA-STMT-2023), FAQ: \"What are the Artemis Accords?\".",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "FAQ: \"What are the Artemis Accords?\": \"Non-signatory Participation\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:ESA-STMT-2023"
  },
  {
   "id": "e389",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-012",
   "target": "instrument:cn-lep4-2024",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in SCIO briefing on \"China’s Space Program: A 2021 Perspective\" (lunar exploration Phase 4) (CN-LEP4-2024), SCIO briefing, 28 January 2022 (Wu Yanhua, CNSA).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "SCIO briefing, 28 January 2022 (Wu Yanhua, CNSA): \"Phase 4 Exploration\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:CN-LEP4-2024"
  },
  {
   "id": "e390",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-013",
   "target": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Artemis Accords (AA-2020), Section 1 (Purpose and Scope), second paragraph.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Section 1 (Purpose and Scope), second paragraph: \"As Appropriate\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:AA-2020"
  },
  {
   "id": "e391",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-015",
   "target": "instrument:in-isp-2023",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Indian Space Policy 2023 (IN-ISP-2023), Definitions, no. 1; Section 5.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Definitions, no. 1; Section 5: \"Authorisation by IN-SPACe\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:IN-ISP-2023"
  },
  {
   "id": "e392",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-016",
   "target": "instrument:nasa-lunanet",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in LunaNet Interoperability Specification (Version 5) (NASA-LUNANET), Section 1 (Introduction).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Section 1 (Introduction): \"Interoperability Standards\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:NASA-LUNANET"
  },
  {
   "id": "e393",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-017",
   "target": "instrument:lux-srl-2017",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in Luxembourg Space Resources Law (LUX-SRL-2017), 51 U.S.C. 51303 / Luxembourg Art. 1.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "51 U.S.C. 51303 / Luxembourg Art. 1: \"Ownership vs. Appropriation\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:LUX-SRL-2017"
  },
  {
   "id": "e394",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:dp-017",
   "target": "instrument:us-cslca-2015",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar discretion point is located in U.S. Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act (US-CSLCA-2015), 51 U.S.C. 51303 / Luxembourg Art. 1.",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "51 U.S.C. 51303 / Luxembourg Art. 1: \"Ownership vs. Appropriation\"",
   "via": "discretionPoints:US-CSLCA-2015"
  },
  {
   "id": "e395",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-usa",
   "target": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"Artemis Accords\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Artemis Accords",
   "via": "countries:doc-usa-01"
  },
  {
   "id": "e396",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-usa",
   "target": "instrument:us-ostp-ltc-2024",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"OSTP Coordinated Lunar Time (LTC) Framework\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "OSTP Coordinated Lunar Time (LTC) Framework",
   "via": "countries:doc-usa-02"
  },
  {
   "id": "e397",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-china",
   "target": "instrument:ilrs-guide-2023",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"ILRS Guide for Partnership (V1.0, CNSA and Roscosmos)\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "ILRS Guide for Partnership (V1.0, CNSA and Roscosmos)",
   "via": "countries:doc-cn-01"
  },
  {
   "id": "e398",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-china",
   "target": "instrument:cn-lep4-2024",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"SCIO briefing on \"China’s Space Program: A 2021 Perspective\" (lunar exploration Phase 4)\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "SCIO briefing on \"China’s Space Program: A 2021 Perspective\" (lunar exploration Phase 4)",
   "via": "countries:doc-cn-02"
  },
  {
   "id": "e399",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-russia",
   "target": "instrument:ilrs-mou-2021",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"China–Russia intergovernmental Memorandum of Understanding on the ILRS (9 March 2021)\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "China–Russia intergovernmental Memorandum of Understanding on the ILRS (9 March 2021)",
   "via": "countries:doc-ru-01"
  },
  {
   "id": "e400",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-japan",
   "target": "instrument:jp-bsl-2008",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"Japan Basic Space Law\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Japan Basic Space Law",
   "via": "countries:doc-jp-01"
  },
  {
   "id": "e401",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-japan",
   "target": "instrument:jp-nasa-2022",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"JAXA-NASA Artemis MoU (Gateway / HLS)\" (document id, no discretion point).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "JAXA-NASA Artemis MoU (Gateway / HLS)",
   "via": "countries:doc-jp-02"
  },
  {
   "id": "e402",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-india",
   "target": "instrument:in-isp-2023",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"Indian Space Policy 2023\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Indian Space Policy 2023",
   "via": "countries:doc-in-01"
  },
  {
   "id": "e403",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-luxembourg",
   "target": "instrument:lux-srl-2017",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"Luxembourg Space Resources Law\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Luxembourg Space Resources Law",
   "via": "countries:doc-lu-01"
  },
  {
   "id": "e404",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-uae",
   "target": "instrument:uae-law-2019",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"UAE Federal Law No. 12 of 2019 on the Regulation of the Space Sector\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "UAE Federal Law No. 12 of 2019 on the Regulation of the Space Sector",
   "via": "countries:doc-ae-01"
  },
  {
   "id": "e405",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:country-esa",
   "target": "instrument:esa-stmt-2023",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar country profile lists the document \"ESA: Gateway MoU and Artemis Accords – FAQs\" (same document id).",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "ESA: Gateway MoU and Artemis Accords – FAQs",
   "via": "countries:doc-esa-01"
  },
  {
   "id": "e406",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:igl-004",
   "target": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar infrastructure link example names Artemis Accords: \"Artemis Accords Section 11 + Luxembourg Space Resources Law\".",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Artemis Accords Section 11 + Luxembourg Space Resources Law",
   "via": "infrastructure:igl-004"
  },
  {
   "id": "e407",
   "kind": "attribute",
   "source": "lunar:igl-004",
   "target": "instrument:lux-srl-2017",
   "basis": "instrument_referenced",
   "basisText": "Lunar infrastructure link example names Luxembourg Space Resources Law: \"Artemis Accords Section 11 + Luxembourg Space Resources Law\".",
   "level": "record",
   "detail": "Artemis Accords Section 11 + Luxembourg Space Resources Law",
   "via": "infrastructure:igl-004"
  },
  {
   "id": "l1",
   "kind": "link",
   "source": "cyber:industroyer2",
   "target": "orbital:21",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "bases": [
    {
     "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
     "basisText": "Both records list MITRE ATT&CK group G0034 (cyber aliases: Sandworm, Voodoo Bear, IRIDIUM; orbital actor: \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\").",
     "via": "mitre:G0034",
     "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
    }
   ],
   "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
   "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
  },
  {
   "id": "l2",
   "kind": "link",
   "source": "cyber:kyivstar",
   "target": "orbital:21",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "bases": [
    {
     "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
     "basisText": "Both records list MITRE ATT&CK group G0034 (cyber aliases: Sandworm, Voodoo Bear, IRIDIUM, Seashell Blizzard; orbital actor: \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\").",
     "via": "mitre:G0034",
     "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
    }
   ],
   "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
   "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
  },
  {
   "id": "l3",
   "kind": "link",
   "source": "cyber:notpetya",
   "target": "orbital:21",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "bases": [
    {
     "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
     "basisText": "Both records list MITRE ATT&CK group G0034 (cyber aliases: Sandworm, Voodoo Bear, IRIDIUM; orbital actor: \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\").",
     "via": "mitre:G0034",
     "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
    }
   ],
   "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
   "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
  },
  {
   "id": "l4",
   "kind": "link",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
   "target": "orbital:21",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "bases": [
    {
     "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
     "basisText": "Both records list MITRE ATT&CK group G0034 (cyber aliases: Sandworm, Voodoo Bear, IRIDIUM; orbital actor: \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\").",
     "via": "mitre:G0034",
     "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
    }
   ],
   "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
   "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
  },
  {
   "id": "l5",
   "kind": "link",
   "source": "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
   "target": "orbital:21",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "bases": [
    {
     "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
     "basisText": "Both records list MITRE ATT&CK group G0034 (cyber aliases: Sandworm, Voodoo Bear, IRIDIUM; orbital actor: \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\").",
     "via": "mitre:G0034",
     "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
    }
   ],
   "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
   "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
  },
  {
   "id": "l6",
   "kind": "link",
   "source": "cyber:viasat-kasat",
   "target": "orbital:21",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "bases": [
    {
     "basis": "same_event",
     "basisText": "One incident recorded in two datasets: cyber case \"Viasat KA-SAT (AcidRain)\" and orbital incident \"Viasat KA-SAT AcidRain Cyberattack\" share the name \"Viasat KA-SAT\" and the year 2022. The orbital record also names the malware AcidRain, listed in the cyber case malwareFamilies.",
     "via": "name",
     "tier": "same-event"
    },
    {
     "basis": "same_event",
     "basisText": "A cited source names both records (https://www.sentinelone.com/labs/acidrain-a-modem-wiper-rains-down-on-europe/), recorded in the relatedRecords field.",
     "via": "related-record",
     "tier": "same-event"
    },
    {
     "basis": "same_event",
     "basisText": "The cyber case target entity \"Viasat KA-SAT\" and the orbital incident target operator \"Viasat\" are the same organisation, in the same year.",
     "via": "target-entity",
     "tier": "same-event"
    },
    {
     "basis": "same_intrusion_set",
     "basisText": "Both records list MITRE ATT&CK group G0034 (cyber aliases: Sandworm; orbital actor: \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\").",
     "via": "mitre:G0034",
     "tier": "same-intrusion-set"
    }
   ],
   "basis": "same_event",
   "tier": "same-event"
  }
 ],
 "stateContext": [
  {
   "state": "state:argentina",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Argentina lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:argentina",
   "instrument": "instrument:tlatelolco",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Argentina lists Tlatelolco Treaty."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:armenia",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Armenia lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:armenia",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Armenia lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:bangladesh",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Bangladesh lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:bangladesh",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Bangladesh lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:bangladesh",
   "instrument": "instrument:tpnw",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Bangladesh lists TPNW."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:belarus",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Belarus lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:belgium",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Belgium lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:belgium",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Belgium lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:belgium",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Belgium lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:brazil",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Brazil lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:brazil",
   "instrument": "instrument:tlatelolco",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Brazil lists Tlatelolco Treaty."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:canada",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Canada lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:canada",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Canada lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:china",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for China lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:czech-republic",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Czech Republic lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:czech-republic",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Czech Republic lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:czech-republic",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Czech Republic lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:egypt",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Egypt lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:finland",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Finland lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:finland",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Finland lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:finland",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Finland lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:france",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for France lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:france",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for France lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:germany",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Germany lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:germany",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Germany lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:germany",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Germany lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:hungary",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Hungary lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:hungary",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Hungary lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:hungary",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Hungary lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:iran",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Iran lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:japan",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Japan lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:japan",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Japan lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:mexico",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Mexico lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:mexico",
   "instrument": "instrument:tlatelolco",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Mexico lists Tlatelolco Treaty."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:mexico",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Mexico lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:mexico",
   "instrument": "instrument:tpnw",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Mexico lists TPNW."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:netherlands",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Netherlands lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:netherlands",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Netherlands lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:netherlands",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Netherlands lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:romania",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Romania lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:romania",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Romania lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:romania",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Romania lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:russia",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Russia lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:slovenia",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Slovenia lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:slovenia",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Slovenia lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:slovenia",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Slovenia lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:south-africa",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for South Africa lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:south-africa",
   "instrument": "instrument:pelindaba",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for South Africa lists Pelindaba Treaty."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:south-africa",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for South Africa lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:south-africa",
   "instrument": "instrument:tpnw",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for South Africa lists TPNW."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:south-korea",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for South Korea lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:south-korea",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for South Korea lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:spain",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Spain lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:spain",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Spain lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:spain",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Spain lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:sweden",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Sweden lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:sweden",
   "instrument": "instrument:euratom",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Sweden lists EURATOM."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:sweden",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Sweden lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:switzerland",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Switzerland lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:switzerland",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Switzerland lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:turkey",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Turkey lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:turkey",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Turkey lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:ukraine",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Ukraine lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:ukraine",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for Ukraine lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for United Arab Emirates lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "instrument": "instrument:iaea-additional-protocol",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for United Arab Emirates lists Additional Protocol."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-kingdom",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for United Kingdom lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-states",
   "instrument": "instrument:npt",
   "domain": "nuclear",
   "status": "listed",
   "basisText": "Nuclear atlas countryGovernance.treaty_obligations for United States lists NPT."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-states",
   "instrument": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: United States, Outer Space Treaty (1967) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-states",
   "instrument": "instrument:liability-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: United States, Liability Convention (1972) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-states",
   "instrument": "instrument:registration-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: United States, Registration Convention (1975) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-states",
   "instrument": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "adopted",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: United States, COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019) = adopted."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-states",
   "instrument": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "signatory",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: United States, Artemis Accords = signatory."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-states",
   "instrument": "instrument:itu-framework",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "compliant",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: United States, ITU Coordination = compliant."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:russia",
   "instrument": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Russia, Outer Space Treaty (1967) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:russia",
   "instrument": "instrument:liability-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Russia, Liability Convention (1972) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:russia",
   "instrument": "instrument:registration-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Russia, Registration Convention (1975) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:russia",
   "instrument": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "partially_adopted",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Russia, COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019) = partially_adopted."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:russia",
   "instrument": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "non_signatory",
   "positive": false,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Russia, Artemis Accords = non_signatory."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:russia",
   "instrument": "instrument:itu-framework",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "compliant",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Russia, ITU Coordination = compliant."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:china",
   "instrument": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: China, Outer Space Treaty (1967) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:china",
   "instrument": "instrument:liability-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: China, Liability Convention (1972) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:china",
   "instrument": "instrument:registration-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: China, Registration Convention (1975) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:china",
   "instrument": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "consensus_2019",
   "positive": false,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: China, COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019) = consensus_2019."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:china",
   "instrument": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "non_signatory",
   "positive": false,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: China, Artemis Accords = non_signatory."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:china",
   "instrument": "instrument:itu-framework",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "filings_pending",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: China, ITU Coordination = filings_pending."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:eu-esa",
   "instrument": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: EU / ESA, Outer Space Treaty (1967) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:eu-esa",
   "instrument": "instrument:liability-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: EU / ESA, Liability Convention (1972) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:eu-esa",
   "instrument": "instrument:registration-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: EU / ESA, Registration Convention (1975) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:eu-esa",
   "instrument": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "adopted",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: EU / ESA, COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019) = adopted."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:eu-esa",
   "instrument": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "signatory",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: EU / ESA, Artemis Accords = signatory."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:eu-esa",
   "instrument": "instrument:itu-framework",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "compliant",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: EU / ESA, ITU Coordination = compliant."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:india",
   "instrument": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: India, Outer Space Treaty (1967) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:india",
   "instrument": "instrument:liability-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: India, Liability Convention (1972) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:india",
   "instrument": "instrument:registration-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: India, Registration Convention (1975) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:india",
   "instrument": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "adopted",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: India, COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019) = adopted."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:india",
   "instrument": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "signatory",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: India, Artemis Accords = signatory."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:india",
   "instrument": "instrument:itu-framework",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "compliant",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: India, ITU Coordination = compliant."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:japan",
   "instrument": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Japan, Outer Space Treaty (1967) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:japan",
   "instrument": "instrument:liability-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Japan, Liability Convention (1972) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:japan",
   "instrument": "instrument:registration-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Japan, Registration Convention (1975) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:japan",
   "instrument": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "adopted",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Japan, COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019) = adopted."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:japan",
   "instrument": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "signatory",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Japan, Artemis Accords = signatory."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:japan",
   "instrument": "instrument:itu-framework",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "compliant",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: Japan, ITU Coordination = compliant."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "instrument": "instrument:outer-space-treaty",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: UAE, Outer Space Treaty (1967) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "instrument": "instrument:liability-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: UAE, Liability Convention (1972) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "instrument": "instrument:registration-convention",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "ratified",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: UAE, Registration Convention (1975) = ratified."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "instrument": "instrument:copuos-lts-guidelines",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "adopted",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: UAE, COPUOS LTS Guidelines (2019) = adopted."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "instrument": "instrument:artemis-accords",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "signatory",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: UAE, Artemis Accords = signatory."
  },
  {
   "state": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "instrument": "instrument:itu-framework",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "status": "compliant",
   "positive": true,
   "basisText": "Orbital treaty compliance matrix: UAE, ITU Coordination = compliant."
  }
 ],
 "illustrative": [
  {
   "id": "orbital:901",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "label": "ILLUSTRATIVE — Co-orbital Inspector Shadows Foreign GEO Comsat",
   "date": "2025-03-15",
   "note": "Fictional sample record in the Orbital Risk Tracker. Excluded from all links and real-world counts.",
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/901"
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:902",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "label": "ILLUSTRATIVE — Destructive Direct-Ascent ASAT Test",
   "date": "2025-06-01",
   "note": "Fictional sample record in the Orbital Risk Tracker. Excluded from all links and real-world counts.",
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/902"
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:903",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "label": "ILLUSTRATIVE — Disputed Close Approach Framed as 'Due Regard' Failure",
   "date": "2025-04-10",
   "note": "Fictional sample record in the Orbital Risk Tracker. Excluded from all links and real-world counts.",
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/903"
  },
  {
   "id": "orbital:904",
   "domain": "orbital",
   "label": "ILLUSTRATIVE — Contested Signal Outage, No Prevailing Framing",
   "date": "2025-05-22",
   "note": "Fictional sample record in the Orbital Risk Tracker. Excluded from all links and real-world counts.",
   "url": "https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app/#/incidents/904"
  }
 ],
 "facets": [
  {
   "entity": "state:china",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "China",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "actor": [
      "cyber:exchange-hafnium",
      "cyber:storm-0558",
      "cyber:volt-typhoon",
      "cyber:opm-breach",
      "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
      "cyber:salt-typhoon",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "orbital": {
     "actor": [
      "orbital:2",
      "orbital:7",
      "orbital:12",
      "orbital:26"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:cn-qinshan",
      "nuclear:cn-daya-bay",
      "nuclear:cn-tianwan",
      "nuclear:cn-hongyanhe",
      "nuclear:cn-yangjiang",
      "nuclear:cn-taishan"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "profiled": [
      "lunar:country-china"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:india",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "India",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:india-pakistan-cyber",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "orbital": {
     "actor": [
      "orbital:16"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:in-kudankulam",
      "nuclear:in-tarapur",
      "nuclear:in-rajasthan"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "profiled": [
      "lunar:country-india"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:russia",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Russia",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "actor": [
      "cyber:notpetya",
      "cyber:solarwinds",
      "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
      "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
      "cyber:viasat-kasat",
      "cyber:industroyer2",
      "cyber:midnight-blizzard",
      "cyber:kyivstar"
     ]
    },
    "orbital": {
     "actor": [
      "orbital:8",
      "orbital:9",
      "orbital:10",
      "orbital:13",
      "orbital:14",
      "orbital:15",
      "orbital:17",
      "orbital:19",
      "orbital:20",
      "orbital:21",
      "orbital:22",
      "orbital:23",
      "orbital:24",
      "orbital:27"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:ru-balakovo",
      "nuclear:ru-leningrad",
      "nuclear:ru-kalinin",
      "nuclear:ru-smolensk",
      "nuclear:ru-beloyarsk"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "profiled": [
      "lunar:country-russia"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:united-states",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "United States",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:solarwinds",
      "cyber:sony-pictures",
      "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
      "cyber:oldsmar-water",
      "cyber:exchange-hafnium",
      "cyber:scattered-spider-mgm",
      "cyber:storm-0558",
      "cyber:change-healthcare",
      "cyber:volt-typhoon",
      "cyber:midnight-blizzard",
      "cyber:opm-breach",
      "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
      "cyber:salt-typhoon",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "orbital": {
     "actor": [
      "orbital:3"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:us-palo-verde",
      "nuclear:us-vogtle",
      "nuclear:us-south-texas",
      "nuclear:us-diablo-canyon",
      "nuclear:us-peach-bottom",
      "nuclear:us-braidwood",
      "nuclear:us-comanche-peak",
      "nuclear:us-watts-bar",
      "nuclear:us-browns-ferry",
      "nuclear:us-calvert-cliffs",
      "nuclear:us-seabrook",
      "nuclear:us-millstone",
      "nuclear:us-north-anna",
      "nuclear:us-oconee",
      "nuclear:us-grand-gulf",
      "nuclear:us-turkey-point",
      "nuclear:us-columbia",
      "nuclear:us-indian-point",
      "nuclear:us-three-mile-island",
      "nuclear:us-san-onofre"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "profiled": [
      "lunar:country-usa"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "sector:communications",
   "type": "sector",
   "label": "Communications",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "category": [
      "cyber:wannacry",
      "cyber:viasat-kasat",
      "cyber:taiwan-telecom",
      "cyber:volt-typhoon",
      "cyber:kyivstar",
      "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist",
      "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
      "cyber:salt-typhoon",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "orbital": {
     "category": [
      "orbital:6",
      "orbital:10",
      "orbital:21",
      "orbital:22"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "category": [
      "lunar:igl-002"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "sector:energy-power",
   "type": "sector",
   "label": "Energy and power",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "category": [
      "cyber:stuxnet",
      "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
      "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
      "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
      "cyber:viasat-kasat",
      "cyber:shamoon-aramco",
      "cyber:iran-nuclear-cyber",
      "cyber:industroyer2",
      "cyber:volt-typhoon",
      "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
      "cyber:flame-flamer"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "category": [
      "nuclear:us-palo-verde",
      "nuclear:us-vogtle",
      "nuclear:us-south-texas",
      "nuclear:us-diablo-canyon",
      "nuclear:us-peach-bottom",
      "nuclear:us-braidwood",
      "nuclear:us-comanche-peak",
      "nuclear:us-watts-bar",
      "nuclear:us-browns-ferry",
      "nuclear:us-calvert-cliffs",
      "nuclear:us-seabrook",
      "nuclear:us-millstone",
      "nuclear:us-north-anna",
      "nuclear:us-oconee",
      "nuclear:us-grand-gulf",
      "nuclear:us-turkey-point",
      "nuclear:us-columbia",
      "nuclear:us-indian-point",
      "nuclear:us-three-mile-island",
      "nuclear:us-san-onofre",
      "nuclear:fr-gravelines",
      "nuclear:fr-cattenom",
      "nuclear:fr-paluel",
      "nuclear:fr-flamanville",
      "nuclear:fr-chinon",
      "nuclear:fr-blayais",
      "nuclear:cn-qinshan",
      "nuclear:cn-daya-bay",
      "nuclear:cn-tianwan",
      "nuclear:cn-hongyanhe",
      "nuclear:cn-yangjiang",
      "nuclear:cn-taishan",
      "nuclear:ru-balakovo",
      "nuclear:ru-leningrad",
      "nuclear:ru-kalinin",
      "nuclear:ru-smolensk",
      "nuclear:ru-beloyarsk",
      "nuclear:kr-kori",
      "nuclear:kr-hanul",
      "nuclear:kr-hanbit",
      "nuclear:ca-bruce",
      "nuclear:ca-darlington",
      "nuclear:ca-pickering",
      "nuclear:gb-sizewell-b",
      "nuclear:gb-heysham",
      "nuclear:gb-torness",
      "nuclear:gb-hinkley-c",
      "nuclear:jp-sendai",
      "nuclear:jp-genkai",
      "nuclear:jp-takahama",
      "nuclear:jp-fukushima-daini",
      "nuclear:in-kudankulam",
      "nuclear:in-tarapur",
      "nuclear:in-rajasthan",
      "nuclear:ua-zaporizhzhia",
      "nuclear:ua-rivne",
      "nuclear:ua-south-ukraine",
      "nuclear:fi-olkiluoto",
      "nuclear:fi-loviisa",
      "nuclear:se-forsmark",
      "nuclear:se-ringhals",
      "nuclear:be-doel",
      "nuclear:be-tihange",
      "nuclear:cz-dukovany",
      "nuclear:cz-temelin",
      "nuclear:hu-paks",
      "nuclear:es-almaraz",
      "nuclear:es-cofrentes",
      "nuclear:ch-leibstadt",
      "nuclear:ch-beznau",
      "nuclear:de-isar",
      "nuclear:nl-borssele",
      "nuclear:ae-barakah",
      "nuclear:ar-atucha",
      "nuclear:br-angra",
      "nuclear:za-koeberg",
      "nuclear:pk-kanupp",
      "nuclear:ir-bushehr",
      "nuclear:mx-laguna-verde",
      "nuclear:ro-cernavoda",
      "nuclear:si-krsko",
      "nuclear:am-metsamor",
      "nuclear:by-ostrovets",
      "nuclear:bd-rooppur",
      "nuclear:tr-akkuyu",
      "nuclear:eg-el-dabaa"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "category": [
      "lunar:igl-003"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:japan",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Japan",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "lunar",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:jp-sendai",
      "nuclear:jp-genkai",
      "nuclear:jp-takahama",
      "nuclear:jp-fukushima-daini"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "profiled": [
      "lunar:country-japan"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:bangladesh",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Bangladesh",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:bangladesh-bank-swift"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:bd-rooppur"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:belgium",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Belgium",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:be-doel",
      "nuclear:be-tihange"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:brazil",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Brazil",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:br-angra"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:canada",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Canada",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:ca-bruce",
      "nuclear:ca-darlington",
      "nuclear:ca-pickering"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:egypt",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Egypt",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:apt-c23-gaza-cybergang",
      "cyber:flame-flamer"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:eg-el-dabaa"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:france",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "France",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:viasat-kasat",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:fr-gravelines",
      "nuclear:fr-cattenom",
      "nuclear:fr-paluel",
      "nuclear:fr-flamanville",
      "nuclear:fr-chinon",
      "nuclear:fr-blayais"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:germany",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Germany",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:viasat-kasat",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:de-isar"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:iran",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Iran",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:stuxnet",
      "cyber:iran-nuclear-cyber",
      "cyber:flame-flamer"
     ],
     "actor": [
      "cyber:albania-iran"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:ir-bushehr"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "sector:navigation-timing",
   "type": "sector",
   "label": "Navigation and timing",
   "domains": [
    "lunar",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "orbital": {
     "category": [
      "orbital:5",
      "orbital:6",
      "orbital:11",
      "orbital:13",
      "orbital:15",
      "orbital:18",
      "orbital:23",
      "orbital:25",
      "orbital:28"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "category": [
      "lunar:igl-001"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:netherlands",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Netherlands",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:nl-borssele"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:north-korea",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "North Korea",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "orbital"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "actor": [
      "cyber:sony-pictures",
      "cyber:wannacry",
      "cyber:bangladesh-bank-swift"
     ]
    },
    "orbital": {
     "actor": [
      "orbital:6",
      "orbital:11"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:pakistan",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Pakistan",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:india-pakistan-cyber"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:pk-kanupp"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:south-korea",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "South Korea",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:kr-kori",
      "nuclear:kr-hanul",
      "nuclear:kr-hanbit"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:sweden",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Sweden",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:se-forsmark",
      "nuclear:se-ringhals"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:switzerland",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Switzerland",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:ch-leibstadt",
      "nuclear:ch-beznau"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:ukraine",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "Ukraine",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:notpetya",
      "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2015",
      "cyber:ukraine-power-grid-2016",
      "cyber:viasat-kasat",
      "cyber:industroyer2",
      "cyber:kyivstar"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:ua-zaporizhzhia",
      "nuclear:ua-rivne",
      "nuclear:ua-south-ukraine"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:united-arab-emirates",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "United Arab Emirates",
   "domains": [
    "lunar",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:ae-barakah"
     ]
    },
    "lunar": {
     "profiled": [
      "lunar:country-uae"
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "entity": "state:united-kingdom",
   "type": "state",
   "label": "United Kingdom",
   "domains": [
    "cyber",
    "nuclear"
   ],
   "byDomain": {
    "cyber": {
     "target": [
      "cyber:solarwinds",
      "cyber:apt1-pla-61398",
      "cyber:cloud-hopper-apt10"
     ],
     "actor": [
      "cyber:belgacom-operation-socialist"
     ]
    },
    "nuclear": {
     "host": [
      "nuclear:gb-sizewell-b",
      "nuclear:gb-heysham",
      "nuclear:gb-torness",
      "nuclear:gb-hinkley-c"
     ]
    }
   }
  }
 ],
 "checks": [
  {
   "id": "same-incident-viasat-kasat",
   "severity": "info",
   "title": "Viasat KA-SAT: cyber and orbital records compared",
   "detail": "Date: cyber dateRange \"February 2022\" (escalation phases 2022-02-24, 2022-02-24, 2022-02-24) vs orbital date 2022-02-24: consistent. Acting state: cyber \"Russia\" vs orbital \"Russia (GRU Sandworm)\": consistent. Sources: cyber cites 3, orbital cites 4. Shared (same URL): Viasat: KA-SAT Network Cyber Attack Overview; Guerrero-Saade & Chen (SentinelOne Labs): AcidRain — A Modem Wiper Rains Down on Europe; Council of the EU: Declaration by the High Representative on Russian cyber operations against Ukraine (Viasat/KA-SAT). Orbital only: CISA/FBI AA22-076A: Strengthening Cybersecurity of SATCOM Network Providers and Customers.",
   "records": [
    "cyber:viasat-kasat",
    "orbital:21"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "source-branch-cyber",
   "severity": "warning",
   "title": "Cyber Escalation Atlas was read from branch claude/gtc-hardening, not the deployed branch",
   "detail": "The snapshot read cyber-escalation-atlas at claude/gtc-hardening (8bc0031). The production site https://cyber-escalation-atlas.vercel.app, which record links open, is built from claude/setup-cyber-atlas-scaffold-ieuDR. Records, fields and counts on the linked pages can differ from this snapshot until that branch is deployed.",
   "records": []
  },
  {
   "id": "source-branch-orbital",
   "severity": "warning",
   "title": "Orbital Risk Tracker was read from branch claude/gtc-hardening, not the deployed branch",
   "detail": "The snapshot read Orbital-Risk-Tracker at claude/gtc-hardening (e219b82). The production site https://orbitalrisktracker.vercel.app, which record links open, is built from claude/space-incidents-dashboard-HOnqa. Records, fields and counts on the linked pages can differ from this snapshot until that branch is deployed.",
   "records": []
  },
  {
   "id": "source-branch-nuclear",
   "severity": "warning",
   "title": "Global Nuclear Infrastructure Atlas was read from branch claude/gtc-hardening, not the deployed branch",
   "detail": "The snapshot read Global-Nuclear-Infrastructure-Atlas at claude/gtc-hardening (daadd82). The production site https://globalnuclearinfrastructureatlas.vercel.app, which record links open, is built from claude/nuclear-infrastructure-atlas-IIjPg. Records, fields and counts on the linked pages can differ from this snapshot until that branch is deployed.",
   "records": []
  },
  {
   "id": "source-branch-lunar",
   "severity": "warning",
   "title": "Lunar Governance Tracker was read from branch claude/gtc-hardening, not the deployed branch",
   "detail": "The snapshot read lunar-mandate-atlas at claude/gtc-hardening (d3d48a1). The production site https://lunar-mandate-atlas.vercel.app, which record links open, is built from claude/lunar-governance-tracker-txA5R. Records, fields and counts on the linked pages can differ from this snapshot until that branch is deployed.",
   "records": []
  },
  {
   "id": "actor-state-not-resolved",
   "severity": "info",
   "title": "Actor fields not resolved to a state",
   "detail": "13 records name a state in the actor field but are not linked to it: cyber:stuxnet (\"United States / Israel\": attribution confidence \"moderate\" is below high); cyber:colonial-pipeline (\"Russia (criminal, not directly state-sponsored per US assessment)\": qualifier says the actor is not the state); cyber:costa-rica-conti (\"Russia (criminal, not directly state-sponsored per public assessments)\": qualifier says the actor is not the state); cyber:shamoon-aramco (\"Iran (assessed)\": attribution confidence \"moderate\" is below high); cyber:iran-nuclear-cyber (\"Israel (attributed by Iran; not officially confirmed)\": attribution confidence \"low\" is below high); cyber:taiwan-telecom (\"China (assessed)\": attribution confidence \"moderate\" is below high); cyber:scattered-spider-mgm (\"United States / United Kingdom (individuals; not state-sponsored)\": qualifier says the actor is not the state); cyber:change-healthcare (\"Russia (criminal, possible state nexus)\": qualifier says the actor is not the state); cyber:india-pakistan-cyber (\"India / Pakistan (reciprocal)\": attribution confidence \"moderate\" is below high); cyber:flame-flamer (\"United States / Israel\": attribution confidence \"moderate\" is below high); orbital:1 (\"China\": attribution confidence \"medium\" is below high); orbital:4 (\"China\": attribution confidence \"medium\" is below high); orbital:5 (\"Iran\": attribution confidence \"medium\" is below high).",
   "records": [
    "cyber:stuxnet",
    "cyber:colonial-pipeline",
    "cyber:costa-rica-conti",
    "cyber:shamoon-aramco",
    "cyber:iran-nuclear-cyber",
    "cyber:taiwan-telecom",
    "cyber:scattered-spider-mgm",
    "cyber:change-healthcare",
    "cyber:india-pakistan-cyber",
    "cyber:flame-flamer",
    "orbital:1",
    "orbital:4",
    "orbital:5"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "nuclear-cyber-ref-kr-kori",
   "severity": "info",
   "title": "Kori / Shin-Kori Nuclear Power Plant: reported cyber incident has no cyber atlas case",
   "detail": "The nuclear atlas records 2014 incident (Documents leaked from operator network; no control-system compromise reported) with source https://nextgov.com/cybersecurity/2014/12/breach/143556. The cyber atlas has no case for it, so no link is drawn.",
   "records": [
    "nuclear:kr-kori"
   ]
  }
 ],
 "limitations": [
  "All four source datasets are analyst-coded from public sources. Coding choices in those datasets carry into this layer.",
  "The datasets are not exhaustive. A missing link means no link can be derived from the coded fields, not that no relationship exists.",
  "Facets (a state or infrastructure category present in two datasets) show co-occurrence in the data, not causation, coordination or a relationship between the records.",
  "The cyber atlas lists target sectors and target countries separately, so a case that lists energy and Germany does not say it targeted the German energy sector.",
  "Instrument references show which instruments each dataset associates with a record. Orbital incident and nuclear plant records reference no instrument at record level, so instrument coverage reflects the schema of each dataset, not a legal conclusion that no law applies.",
  "Free-text fields (summaries, policy responses) are not parsed for links, except the short keyword rules listed in the sector crosswalk.",
  "This layer describes recorded events. It makes no prediction."
 ]
}